Question:
Can I make a milkshake using SF Ice Cream?
Can I make a milkshake using SF/Low fat ice cream-I am probably going to put protein powder in it, but I am not sure at this moment. Also since sf ice cream is like a liquid, how much can others eat of it. I am also going to use some sf atkins choc. syrup? Will this be ok — TotallyTori (posted on May 3, 2003)
May 3, 2003
You should use Ice,water and a protein powder like muscle milk, 32 g of
protein per serving. It also taste good, and it only has 6g of sugers
(sucalose) per serving so it will not make you dump. good luck and try to
remember what lead us to WLS (SF/Low fat ice cream ?)
— sanfam93
May 3, 2003
I have to agree with Jose, the previous poster. I would not chance using
SF icecream. There is LOADS of lactose, (milk sugar) in that stuff, and
would probably make you dump. Try to chose something more WLS friendly if
you have a sweet tooth. I know I can't fool myself into thinking that SF
foods didn't make me gain weight... I lived on them and got very big.
— Happy I.
May 3, 2003
As long as its a occasional TREAT such a shake is fine. Milk is suggested
by many nutronists. But DONT make it a habit!!!! It could cause weight
regain.
— bob-haller
May 3, 2003
water, ice, and ice cream-sounds disgusting to me-Sorry. I appreciate the
posts thus far, I don;t have a problem with milk and I use milk to bled
with my protein shakes, 4oz of milk and 4 oz of water, so total a day I
only have 8oz of milk,but I am not going to mix water with ice cream, I
hear people eating protein bars all day long and they are loaded with fat
and calories-I don;t really think milk sugar is going to make me gain
weight, and I could be wrong but I have seen plenty of post-opers say that
they drink and tolerate milk, as do I. I also don;t understand what is
wrong with sf ice cream,a 1/2 cup is 110 cals-I don't think that is bad,
and I figure as long as it is calculated into my daily calories 800cals
tops at 8 weeks, that I should be fine.
— TotallyTori
May 3, 2003
Hey, Tori. "I" understand. We're still at the
"boring" stage. Last night I made my "shake" with an
80 calorie (Axelrod's, not sure if it's available in Philly) vanilla
yogurt, 1 or 2 oz of skim plus, 5ish ice cubes and the powder. It was
truly yummy and thick. I ate it with a spoon. How many calories? I guess
about 10 for the milk, 80 for the yogurt, and 90 for the powder. I think a
180 calorie "treat" is great! You're doing swell. Don't worry,
I understand. BTW, I ordered the nectar, very cherry berry. Well, I think
its berry gross by itself. So instead of flushing my money away, I added
1/2 scoop of the berry cherry and a 1/2 scoop of designer whey chocolate to
water and ice and had myself a cherry garcia treat!! Proteinly yours! and
good luck! Your friend, Mary
— msmaryk
May 3, 2003
Everyone is different....give it a try! But as with everything watch your
portion and calories. I am suppose to get 4 servings of milk a day. I
have some Blue Bunny no sugar added creamscicles that I ocasionally have as
a milk but not often since they don't have as much protein as other milk
products do. And as a side note...I've had potatoes everyday since surgery
and now I can have pasta. Like I said everyone is different and following
different dietary instructions. I myself believe in a balanced diet.
— Sarahlicious
May 3, 2003
I occasionally throw some sf ice cream (about a scoop) into a protein
drink. I use Lactaid when I use chocolate or vanilla protein powders.
Since surgery I have had a problem drinking choc and van and I get sick of
the fruit flavored ones. I throw the ice cream in to make it more
palatable. I have done it twice in 16 weeks but both times I had no
problem.
— susanje
May 3, 2003
I never used the protien powders, but as an early post op I used both
Healthy Choice Vanilla and their Mint SF ice cream to make milk shakes. :)
Very tasty when nothing else tasted good.
— Danmark
May 3, 2003
I am just shocked at the amount of carbs many of you are putting in your
bodies. Where's the protein that is supposed to be the focus for WLS
patients? Sugar aside all of these various SF ice creams etc. are loaded
with carbs and many times fat. Good thing I never was into shakes much
before surgery. I bought some no sugar added ice cream bars a few weeks
ago that have 12 grams of carbs (including 2 grams of sugar) and I had a
hard time bringing myself to even try it as I rarely eat 12 grams of carbs
in a meal. It does have a little bit of protein, like a few grams but I am
not using them as a meal but as an occassional snack. I won't be eating
them much as normally my snacks, if I have any, are protein. I guess I am
the weird one but my plan says PROTEIN.
— zoedogcbr
May 3, 2003
Chris...I am happy for you and your weight-loss, but you have got to
lighten up! Low carbs may be the way for you and many people out here,
but it is not the *only* way. My nutritionist says protein FIRST, not
protein exclusively. All of the three macronutriets - protein, carbs and
fats - are needed.
<p>
Protein is essential for growth and development. It provides the body with
energy, and is needed for the manufacture of hormones, antibodies, enzymes,
and tissues. It also helps maintain the proper acid-alkali balance in the
body. Protein provides energy at 4 calories per gram, but it is more
important as the body's building material. <p>
Carbohydrates supply the body with the energy it needs to function. They
are found almost exclusively in plant foods, such as fruits, vegetables,
peas, and beans. Milk and milk products are the only foods derived from
animals that contain a significant amount of carbohydrates.
<p>
Fats are used to make skin and body oils, regulate your body by forming
hormones, insulate and pad internal organs, carry fat-soluble vitamins
throughout the body, help repair damaged tissue and fight infections, and
provide a source of energy.
<p>
The mixture of protein/carbs/fats in the diet should be - in a maintenance
mode - about 30%/50%/20%. During the window of opportunity, you could
probably flip the first two numbers and go 50%/30%/20%, but you really
don't want to eliminate the carbs from your diet - especially if you are
exercising. Athletes before a competition don't protein load - they carb
load. This is because the carbs provide the energy for their exercise.
<p>
I wouldn't drink these milk shakes 100% of the time, because I believe in
moderation in everything we eat. But the person is getting protein from
the SF/low fat ice cream and protein from the milk and protein from the
protein powder, so the drink won't be completely without nutritional
benefit...JR
— John Rushton
May 3, 2003
I am currently 20mths out, and let me say that looking for that perfect
sugarfree dessert is not a good thing. You are just substituting worse
crap for something else. For 1, just because it is sugar free, doesn't
mean it is calorie free. 2. I don't know about you, but I became lactose
intolerant after surgery and a shake made from any type of dairy product
would definetly make me dump...sugarfree or not. 3. The last poster was
correct, check out the carbs! Check out the carbs on any reduced fat or
low fat or sugar free item...you will find sometimes the carb count is
DOUBLE the amount of the "real stuff." If you are looking for a
protein shake with a little umph to it...just use water & icecubes
& a little REGULAR fat peanutbutter (reduce fat has more sugar &
more carbs than regular) and that will give you some thickness. The little
bit of peanut butter takes away the "proteiny" taste. I like the
Champion Nutrition Pure Protein Whey Stack in chocolate - it mixes with 5
ounces of water & you don't even need to use a blender if you don't
want to. Again, try to stay away from the s/f desserts. They aren't going
to help you lose weight.
— Ilene M.
May 4, 2003
Contrary to some of the more drastic anti-carb opinions, I think I feel
more normal if I do allow myself an occasional treat. And to me, I couldn't
go on living without ice cream in some form!!! I've made "shakes"
with both protein powder and No Sugar Added Carnation Instant Breakfast. I
love the Blue Bunny NSA Ice Creams, available in reduced fat or fat free.
Throw an envelope of vanilla NSA CIB or a scoop of protein powder, in with
1/2 - 1 cup milk, a couple small scoops of ice cream and some frozen
strawberries...yum, yum, yum! You can also try it with chocolate powder and
add your SF syrup, with or without berries. Another thing to liven up CIB
or protein powder is a scoop of frozen Cool Whip Lite and some berries, not
so much a milkshake but creamy and tasty. I just make sure I don't do this
daily! :o Enjoy!
— Anna L.
May 4, 2003
Not to get off the subject, but I have never counted any calories,
carbs....nothing! My surgeon set a goal on protien and I try to get it all
in everyday. I was told I'd never have to worry about that stuff
again(counting calories and carbs)and I sure don't, just watch the sugar
and high fat foods so I don't dump! I don't want to ever diet again! I lost
over 100lbs in the first 6mo and I was a featherweight(as I have been
called, so I should have lost slower). I eat crystal light slurpees, SF
candy and ice cream, chips...ect. In moderation and I get my protien in and
im still losing :o) We all do this our own way and we know our Doctors and
nutritionists all tell us something different, for we all had different
surgeries at different locations.
Now as for the shake(lol)....SF ice cream, a scoop of powder protien and a
couple scoops of No Sugar added Nestle Quick chocolate milk powder Mmmmm
it's so good! I can drink about 1 cup myself, just takes me a long time
lol. Good luck and enjoy!
— Sandy M.
May 4, 2003
I do not believe one should go without carbs...My Doctor says that this
surgery is to aid you in being a normal eating person. Normal people eat
carbs. And YES, our bodies need carbs...so with that said here is a treat
I like...One of the things I missed most was a banana split and I was
craving one so much...well..in answer to my delima here is what I came up
wiht...OCCASIONALLY....OK?....one half an banana split, add three small
scoops of S/F vanilla ice cream, one teaspoon s/f strawberry jam, one
teaspoon fresh pineapple crushed, and melt in the micowave two hershey semi
sweet cubes with a smidgen of milk and pour over then top with ready whip
and nuts....heaven and I never can eat the whole thing so my husband who
has never weighed over 140...helps..:)))
— Oldsoul
May 4, 2003
I don't think that anyone is saying not to have any carbs. I eat carbs all
the time...it is where you get your carbs from that you need to watch. I
choose to get my carbs from fruits and vegtables. Does this mean that I
don't eat bread, pasta, or desserts? HECK NO. I eat it all, just not all
the time. It also depends how far out you are. Constantly looking for
that ultimate sugar free dessert is just a license to eat more of it. Me,
I stick to my 3 bite rule...I have 3 bites of the real thing and I am done.
AND not 3 GIGANTIC bites, three normal bites. You just have to be smart
about your CALORIE intake. :)
— Ilene M.
May 4, 2003
John, You mean to tell me you have lost all the weight you have and were
eating sugar free ice cream and lots of carbs at 2 months PO. From what I
have read of your posts I do not think that is the case. People who are
significantly post-op are in a whole different than early PO. This person
is an early PO.
<p>My eating plan uses max ketosis so cutting carbs to less than 30
grams per day is critical. It will not be this way forever. Any carbs I
eat usually come from veggies and occassionally fruit and the very
infrequent s/f ice cream bar I mentioned earlier. I have no intention of
not ever eating carbs again like more fruit and bread etc. assuming I can
tolerate it. But indulging in significant carbs early on can trigger all
kinds of cravings for an early PO.
<p>I think it would be helpful if people clarified how far out when
they started some of these things. I realize some eating plans have lots
of carbs and people are allowed to eat mashed potatoes and grits, bread
etc. from very early on. They are on a plan that does not use ketosis very
much so therefore they must get a certain amount of calories and therefore
a lot will have to come from carbs.
<p>The ratios you list for protein etc. are drastically different
from an eating plan that uses max ketosis. For 6 weeks it was nothing but
protein. Then like max 15% of your intake can be from veggies, fruit and
other carbs. That means 85% is protein. Once I am to to a maintenance
eating plan I still must take in at least 50% protein always. I have a
very small pouch and therefore protein will always be more important than
to someone who has a larger pouch and will likely be able to eat more food
than I will.
<p>All I know is that eating s/f foods and tons of carbs is what
brings most people to WLS, so why at 2 months out would someone want to
start tempting themselves with shakes. I guess they have tons more
willpower than I assume I would have at this point if I tried to venture
into sweets etc. For my body, eating normal, will always have to mean that
I limit the amount of refined carbs as they have been my downfall my entire
life and I do not think I am an odd ball in this situation.
— zoedogcbr
May 4, 2003
In addition, my 3 month labs all came back wonderful, so my eating plan is
not harming me in any way. By 4-6 months it will be changing and will
include more carbs, which I plan to provide through more veggies and fruit
and the occassional bit of refined carbs or sweets, but just a bite as I
really am not looking forward to dumping, so right now I chose to live in
fear of dumping. Chris
— zoedogcbr
May 4, 2003
Hi-original poster here again. First off, to all who responded than you so
much. As for Chris D., I do eat protein first all the time, and veggies if
I have room, I hvae stayed away from carbs a whole hell of alot, and I did
not have this surgery not to be able to live a normal life, to become one
oft hose post-ops obsessed with never eating a carb again,never having
sugar-do I want to gain my weight back-of course not I've lost 40lbs in 7
weeks, so something must be damn good. If you intend to obsess over this
and that and eating this and counting that then that is your choice-I had
this surgery to lose and maintain a healthy weight, not to obsess about
what the calorie.fat.protein ration etc is-the main goal is to eat healthy,
exercise and live-you can;t live a normal pos-op life if you can;t eat in
moderation-I have the willpower to make my surgery a success, I may not
have had much be4 surgery, but I damn sure do now seeing this weight off,
maybe you need to have more willpower and discipline because if you did you
would be able to enjoy sf/lowfat.nofat.regular sugar or whatever as an
occasional snack and not criticize someone else for stepping up to do so.
So thank you for your opinion, but I have plenty health advice from other
posters as well as self discipline to suceed-I hope you find some of your
own-insecuirty over food is an issue you seem like you need to deal with.
To everyone else thank you for your wonderful posts.PEace
— TotallyTori
May 4, 2003
I've never counted carbs. I was told to eat protein first, and supplement
with protein shakes, in order to get 70-90 grams per day. I do look at
sugar content, but I admit it, I eat regular sugar, in MODERATION. That's
what this surgery has done for me. I have the power to make better food
choices, because I don't feel like I'm starving all the time. Yanno? I eat
a balanced diet with protein first, then whatever else I want, if there's
room. In MY opinion, the occaisonal treat is a GOOD thing. But, I try to
have a protein shake before I have anything sweet. For me, it helps me eat
less sugar. I don't crave it, if I eat more protein. THAT said, your shake
idea sounds good to me! I can't tolerate milk very much, or else I would
probably eat the SF ice cream occaisonally. I have seen a lot of SF syrups,
but never tried those either. Lemme know how your shake turns out! Hang in
there!
— Diana L.
May 4, 2003
Chris - I go protein first, and I try to watch my carbs, but I don't
restrict them to the extent that you do. If I want some baked potato,
I'll eat some baked potato. However, it's only 1/2 a baked (max) and no
butter/margarine or sour cream on it.
<p>
I've eaten Wendy's chili since week 3 and that's got carbs in it too.
There are other carbs that I eat, but I don't overdo them - I eat them in
moderation. And it's after I get my protein in. Last night at dinner (it
was Geri's and mine 18th wedding anniversary), I ordered a backfin crab
cake for dinner, but at about 25% of it. I ordered a salad and that was
so good (with a strawberry vinaigrette (sp?) dressing on it) that I ate
that. Not many calories and it filled me up. And I took the rest of the
crab cake home and had it later.
<p>
Geri - her last meal before her 2-day liquid diet (she's getting her Lap
RNY on Tuesday) - had the Lobster and Crab Stuffed Mushrooms as an
appetizer (her favorite) and the Rock Lobster Tail for dinner.
<p>
I'm not perfect...I've become less strict on myself as I've gotten further
out and am only 42 pounds from goal (which will be a total of 214 pounds
lost when I get there). But I am definitely eating healthier than I did
pre-op and it's a diet that I will be able to stay on for the long-term and
maintain my weight or even continue to lose at a slower rate. I never was
a believer in Atkins - not when I tried him 27 years ago at the age of 18
nor now...JR
— John Rushton
May 4, 2003
Victoria, The bottom line is I am following my surgeon's plan as close to
100% as much as possible. He has been doing WLS for 15 years and has many
successful patients. As John and many others have posted in the past, it
is very important to follow your surgeon's eating plan for at least 6
months. My plan requires me to greatly restrict carbs for now. I will be
crossing the 100 lbs lost mark probably within a week or 2, so I have
nothing to apologize for. I am almost 13 weeks out. Ask your surgeon what
he thinks about ice cream of any kind at 2 months PO and I doubt it would
be high on his list of appropriate foods. Maybe a bite or two but not a
whole shake.
<p>I'm very glad for you that at 2 months out you have everything
figured out and are able to control your eating like the PO's who are way
out. Just please do yourself a favor and keep your eyes open because it is
not all going to be peaches and cream and don't for a second ever think you
will never struggle with food again. This surgery did not suddenly fix
your pre-op eating issues. They are still there just hidden by the
honeymoom euphoria. Go to the yahoo graduate page and read. It's a real
eye opener.
<p>I have a very realistic understanding of what my eating issues are
and how to work on dealing with them and that is exactly what I am doing.
Taking a proactive approach to find ways to deal with them because I know
they did not suddenly go away because someone cut open my gut.
<p>I'm sure everything will go perfect for you since you have
everything under control.
— zoedogcbr
May 4, 2003
One other component here is that I have a whole lot of weight to lose. 260
lbs if I get to some ideal number in an insurance book. So for me it is
critical to get as much weight off in the early post-op period, 6-8 months.
We all know the weight loss slows down the further out we get, well by one
year I hope to be within 50 lbs of that final number. It will be a
struggle to get all the way but it is going to take quite a bit of
restriction of food and especially carbs to lose 260 lbs. I was a carb
aholic before surgery and I have been amazed how well I have done without
them. If I really want something I have it but just 1-2 bites. I really
haven't missed the pasta, sweets etc.
<p>Since many of you feel I am obsessed then I guess my surgeon is
also, as this is his plan. However, I am willing to follow it because he
has many great success stories behind him with super morbidly obese
patients. He gives us a tiny pouch, longer bypass and avoids the carbs to
maximize ketosis to burn fat. The more carbs you put into your body the
less your body will burn off fat. This is a fact not my opinion. Read
about ketosis and learn for yourself. I lost 3 pants sizes in about 4-5
weeks, even though my weight loss was only around 30 lbs. It went for the
fat on my gut, which was great. I'm now about ready to lose the 5th pants
size. At 355 lbs I am wearing 3X and a few 2X things. All my pre-op
clothes are history and things I haven't worn for 2-3 years are being given
away this next weekend.
<p>I certainly plan to be eating similar to the people who are very
post op at the same stage they are now. I'm not sure I will ever be able
to eat 1/2 a baked potato but I will eat a bunch. Now if I have any it's 1
or 2 small bites and that's fine with me. I can only eat 1/2 cup of food
per meal so there isn't much room for carbs of any kind if I am going to
keep my protein intake up around 50-60 grams.
<p>I realize this plan is not what every surgeon uses but for me it
is great because it does not use any protein supplements, which I detest.
— zoedogcbr
May 5, 2003
Chris, I think John and the others were taking issue with your first post
that said you were "shocked" by Victoria's use of SF ice cream,
and "where was her protein". One thing I think you have seen
here on this board and the graduate board for those further post-op is that
there are different eating plans and they all seem to get you there with
some help on your end to eat right, exercise, water intake etc. Eating as
your doctor has advised is not meant for everyone, and while it would most
likely work for everyone, not everyone prefers to get their weight off the
same way. I never did count carbs, just ensured that protein always came,
and still does, first-then the veggies and fruits and if I have room left
over (which I usually don't) the carb. I do have carbs in protein bars,
and in snacks and have chosen not to count them. Its worked for me to get
me within 7 pounds of goal. So, please, while we appreciate that you have
alot of weight to lose, and I certainly admire your dedication and
willingness to work so hard to get there (and I'm sure you will!) comments
like you are "shocked" are not received well.
Victoria, yes you can use SF ice cream and SF syrup in your protein shake.
Just watch the calories. Try drinking just a small amount in the beginning
to see how your system handles it though. As a new post-op, ya never know
how new things work with the pouch!
— Cindy R.
May 5, 2003
The bottom line is many of you posting to this question are a year or more
post op and I believe telling a 2 mo PO to eat the same way you do now is
not giving the best possible advice.
<p>Many of you keep saying I am chosing to eat this way - this is not
true. I believe I have seen many people on this board and others tell
everyone to follow their surgeon's eating plan for at least 6 months. Am I
wrong? This is what I am doing! Would I prefer to eat lots of carbs etc -
probably, as long as they didn't make me sick. Would I then be following
what my surgeon has asked me to do - No. My surgeon uses this plan with
both MO and SMO and the MO don't seem to have a problem following it
either.
<p>So I'm not sure why everyone wasn't directing Victoria to follow
her surgeon's plan and ask her surgeon if she could use S/F ice cream.
Most of you answering and saying yes you use it are so far out from being 2
months PO. I understand that being further PO allows you to eat different
things and not be as strict. I did not say I was shocked at just Victoria
I just could ot believe the amount of people who are chosing to put ice
cream of any sort etc. in their mouths on what seemed like a fairly regular
basis. I beleive most WL plans indicate that protein has to be the
priority for the rest of your life and at first it's really important to be
the main focus.
<p>I do not count carbs as everyone thinks, I just happen to have a
reasonable idea of the things I eat how many carbs are in it. I educated
myself early on by reading labels so I could make good informed decisions.
I focus mainly on how much protein is in each item and then look at carbs.
Yes I chose many times not to buy something because it has what I consider
quite a bit of carbs. I do not count calories or pay a ton of attention to
fat grams as I know in general the things I chose are very reasonable in
fat.
<p>I have heard John and others post many times that "just
because you can eat it, doesn't mean you should". They then proceed
to ask the person why did they bother to have WLS if they are going for the
foods that got us to WLS to begin with. So why is this situtaion
different?
<p>Yes "shocked" was a strong word and I'm sorry if
everyone was offended. I just could not believe how many people were
telling a 2 mo post-op to go for the ice cream and other stuff, yet many
were long-term post-ops who can get by with eating this stuff. Like
someone else said, eating sugar free stuff is how many people got to WLS.
— zoedogcbr
May 5, 2003
Chris D, WLS god, forgive us for sins.
— Sarahlicious
May 5, 2003
AMOS MOD HERE<P> Everyone PLEASE be nice.<P> I tell everyone to
be very diet compliant during the quick loss phase fore best overall
results. Early compliance can be the difference of getting to goal or
remaining obese. Its up to the individual to decide whats best for them.
New post ops need to know this.
— bob-haller
May 5, 2003
Sorry for my previous post...it is nice to have people share their
experience but too much unsolicited advise gets to be annoying especially
since everyone is different....gained weight differently, chose WLS for
different reasons and have different post-op nutrition guidelines to
follow.
— Sarahlicious
May 5, 2003
Sarah - GET A LIFE!
— zoedogcbr
May 5, 2003
Woah! Peeps!! Put down those cartons of S/F ice cream and back away from
them ... slowwwly ... with your hands up where we can see 'em!<P>This
is one of those threads that shows how much pressure we put on ourselves as
post-ops, because we're all so very paranoid (and rightfully so) about how
to make the surgery work for us. Many of us who lost weight at a nice clip
did so by doing stuff that others of us who *also* lost weight nicely might
find downright appalling, as too "rigid" or as too
"undisciplined." The question here was, "can I" make a
milkshake with s/f ice cream. Yep, 'course you can. "Should I"
is a different question entirely. At two months out, I wouldn't have made
that choice. However, I did have a couple of bites of apple pie a la mode
at that stage once (with regular "mode" ... not sugar free). I
survived (happily). To each his/her own.<P>I don't believe in
limiting carbs as severely as Chris does, but I absolutely have always
counted them, and try hard just to keep my protein grams just ahead of (or
maybe equal to) my carb grams. I can't maintain that ratio without protein
shakes, however, which I actually like (go ahead ... pelt me with s/f ice
cream now if you must). I do not now, nor will I ever, trust myself with
too many (noncomplex) carbs. Personal experience has taught me that they
really prompt awful, relentless cravings for more of the same if I'm not
super-careful to limit them, make compromises to counterbalance them, or
just absolutely keep many of them out of the house and away from me in any
measurable amount. More power to those who can handle them without a big
problem, but I can't.<P>And I don't think it's really fair to suggest
that someone who is pretty Spartan about carbs (on doctor's orders, no
less) lacks discipline and willpower. At two months out, you don't need a
lick of discipline or willpower to lose weight with the pouch. You'll lose
no matter what you plop into it, at that stage. Give it time, but
recognize that for many, many people, living "normally" after WLS
will *not* mean you can eat whatever you want. Chris seems to understand
this very well already; I'm still learning it; and I'm not convinced some
folks who were pretty hard on Chris have even begun to glimpse that reality
yet.
— Suzy C.
May 5, 2003
The only problem I see with mixing sugar free ice cream into a shake is
that you are creating a high-calorie beverage which is really the enemy to
the WLS patient. I think the fear of carbs is secondary. I know I ate a
lot of sugar free yogurt as an early postop and even now and I still lost
weight. Also, there are a lot of carbs in milk and many surgeons and
nutrionists recommend that. My doctor nor his nutritionist ever said
anything about restricting carbs. In fact sugar free popcicles, milk and
toast were part of their eating plans. However; we were supposed to stay
away from sugar for one year. No, I didn't do it, but I tried my best!
— Lisa N M.
May 6, 2003
Geez, I think you have to give yourself a lot of credit for looking for, at
least, a lower calorie, higher nutrition solution here! You know, you could
just go out to the nearest ice cream shop and get a big ol' chocolate
shake, and never post anything here. I seriously doubt you plan to live on
this item, but I suspect it is something you plan to treat yourself with.
How much are we talking here - maybe a 4-6 oz shake? Even once a week, it
won't kill your weigh loss, but if it is an alternative to an unhealthy
choice, go for it. I confess that I have Pierre's Slender Butter Pecan ice
cream in my freezer. I can eat about 1/2 cup, and maybe once a week.
Pre-op, I absoutely loved ice cream. My DH and I would have a big bowl
every night, and it was never the sugar free, low fat stuff, believe me!
If you miss having a chocolate shake, make one and enjoy it!
— koogy
May 6, 2003
I scream, you scream, we're all screaming about ICE CREAM? Oh, come on....
So, Tori, did you have the shake or not!? I really want to know, and I'm
sure ALL of these others do, too. I had some HC NSA Mint Chip last night.
It was good, but the sorbitol gave me soooo much gas, so it wasn't worth
eating again any time soon. I guess "the tool" works. I still
say you're doing GREAT!! You go, girl!! Proteinly yours, Mary P.S. I
ate 2 french fries 1 week ago. (I am still human and tempted by food!!!)
Boy, those two were goooood and that's ALL I wanted. I don't want more
even now!! What a difference from my pre-op fried food obsession days!!
Keep up the good work, Tori!! It's all a learning experience.
— msmaryk
Click Here to Return