JoAnn, Have you tried DANNAN Litght'n Fit Creamy. It has less then 1% of aspartame, 5g's of sugar per surving, 4gs of protein. I hear that a lot of people like it, I know my Husband really likes it a lot. I haven't got to that point, so I haven't tasted it yet. I hope this helps, good luck. Melody DeRose