Question:
Can someone answer this question?
Hi, I have researched the library, but did not find an answer to this-Is RNY gastric bypass surgery an acceptable treatment for a hiatal hernia and severe acid reflux? I do not want to ask my doctor(for obvious reasons) until I get some feedback on this. Thanks in advance! Kelli — kelli4wls (posted on March 18, 2006)
March 18, 2006
No, not really, I have barrette, the worst of the gerd, the fix was /is a
hernia repair and a fundia wrap. the fundai wrap will take the fundus,top
of the eesophagas to squeez it close when it contracts to push food
downward. curd my gerd instantly. now they do this same day,,wow. so it on
the health channel. the rny will reduce gerd somewhat due to weight loss,
but may also agravate it, is not copatible with a wrap, thus I will have a
DS, which as a wl can be done post wrap, but not pre wrap as the fundus is
disponsed of.
Dr Gagner is a authority on this, and he will advise u on email, Barretts
is a very severe,very cancer prone level of Reflux.
— walter A.
March 18, 2006
Depending on who/how your RNY is done, many of us experience complete
relief from these awful symptoms. Mine was over the day of surgery. Poof.
End of misery.
— vitalady
March 18, 2006
My hiatal hernia was repaired and my GERD also is gone. My surgeon said
that he could not guarantee that the GERD would be gone but he thought that
at the least it would be greatly improved. I have been symptom free since
the day of my surgery almost 3 years ago.
— ChristineB
March 19, 2006
I had a "moderate to large" hiatal hernia, and terrible gerd. My
distal RNY took care of it...never had any acid reflux or symptoms of the
hernia again. Been six years now. Regards~
— Statuesque
March 19, 2006
Obviously I think you want to research the Duodenal Switch as an option to
the RNY. There are a number of surgeons who have experience with their
patients being cured of the acid refulx. As Walter said -- Contact Dr
Gagner http://www.cornellweightlosssurgery.com/ He is the Chief, Bariatric
Surgery at Cornell University. If he'd be willing to advise you by e-mail,
you'd be wise to take his advice. Keep doing your research... make the
best choice for you.
— [Deactivated Member]
March 19, 2006
The RNY is a effective treatment for these troubles! For the original
poster. You are trusting the surgeon with your life, so hopefully you will
trust him with your questions.....
— bob-haller
March 20, 2006
You probably have acid reflux because of the hernia. the bypass surgery is
not a "fix" for the hernia, but the Dr. can repair the hernia
while doing the RNY bypass surgery. My Dr. is going to repair my hernia
during surgery. So you get 2 for the price of 1 (smile)
Dawn C
— dande41
March 20, 2006
While having RNY sugery may cure the symptoms you mention; RNY IS NOT the
reason to have this surgery. This is a very very difficult and hard to
recover from surgery (especially open and not lap like mine was in 2001)
RNY is surgery to treat morbid obesity. Being obese to the point that it
will KILL YOU. 100 lbs or more over your ideal weight for your height. IF
that is your case, then you could consider RNY, otherwise, try alternative
surgeries or treatments to cure your problems. While i am a vast supporter
for RNY, there are easier ways to help your problems if you do not need
this surgery. Hugs........ Kim
— Kimberly Felan
Click Here to Return