Question:
Is this the least intrusive surgery and is it available in California yet or at all?

   — Victor M. (posted on November 30, 2000)

November 30, 2000
The Alvarado group in San Diego is participating in the clinical trials.
   — Linda B.

November 30, 2000
I did some research on this procedure because I would've like to have had a less intrusive surgery...but I was not willing to prolong the poor quality of life that was mine for any longer than necessary...and I was not sure how long it would take before my insurance would cover a "new" procedure. I am very, very happy with my open, proximal RNY and if I had to do it over again, I would.
   — Lucky B.

December 1, 2000
On 11/14/00 I had a Lap RNY. I only have 5 little scars (my Dr. even used the self absorbing sutures) I am 2 weeks out, and have not had any problems as far as with sutures or healing. I personally feel this is they was to go. It is surgery, but I was released the next day.
   — Patti S.

January 9, 2001
Hi -- Dr. Carlos Gracia in Pleasanton, CA (SF area) is in the FDA trials. I am a trials patient 13 months post-op and am 5 pounds away from goal -- from 256 to 161. I have been VERY pleased with my band. I didn't get coverage, but my insurance wouldn't cover any WLS for me -- I only had a BMI of 37.5. I paid cash. However, a friend got her band covered through Cigna without a problem. Dr. Wittgrove no longer places bands -- he has effectively quit the trials. I also know of more surgeons throughout the country and around the world who place AGBs. It's really popular internationally, but because of the lengthy trials, it has taken awhile for it to catch on in the States.
   — Layla R.

January 9, 2001
I just met Dr. Wittgrove on 1/05/01. He said he IS STILL participating in the clinical trials but that he WOULD NOT "recommend" this procedure. He said that both him and his partner, Dr. Clark, are "disappointed with the results."
   — CHaTTy C.