Question:
I just saw UCLA's Bariatric Program post op diet & was surprised.
UCLA has the diet on their website. It has Slim Fast--which I thought has a high sugar content--and it also has Tums as the preferred calcium supplement--which I thought wasn't beneficial to post ops. Have I misinterpreted the downside of these 2 products? Are they ok? Please excuse my ignorance. I am pre-op & am tring to disect all the post-op diet/nutrtition info. — mary V. (posted on June 3, 2002)
June 2, 2002
My surgeon is one of the pioneers in the field of bariatric surgery, and he
lists SlimFast as one of the "acceptable" protein supplements and
also tells his patients to take one Tums three times a day as the
"preferred" calcium supplement. He does caution that the
slightly higher sugar content in SlimFast may trigger "dumping"
in more sensitive patients, but my daughter and I used it occasionally for
variety, and never experienced any problems. He only allows his patients
to use protein supplements for the first six weeks post-op, then demands
that they obtain their daily protein requirement from a "normal
diet". So, in that respect, if you tolerate SlimFast without
dumping..... it's less expensive than many supplements, easily found, and
comes in a variety of flavors. For what it's worth, we are 27 and 29
months post-op, have perfect lab values for serum protein and calcium, and
my bone density exam last month was great (56 years old). Every surgeon
and nutritionist seem to have slightly varying opinions on post-op diets
and supplements, and you'll make yourself crazy trying to "copy"
every other post-op's program represented on this site. It's always
important to follow your own surgeon's regimen......you're making a huge
personal and financial investment in having him/her perform your surgery
and manage your aftercare. Generally, if you are faithful in supplementing
your protein as directed, and taking your vitamin/minerals for the rest of
your life, and having labs monitored on a regular basis (1-2 times/year),
you will be great....regardless of the details of the regimen involved.
Good luck!
— Diana T.
June 3, 2002
Mary ~
I had surgery at UCLA on 4/9 & I was surprised at their protocal. Slim
Fast to me is just too high in sugar. I think that UCLA recommends Slim
Fast because it does not cost as much as other protein supplements. I
personally switched to Pro-Complex that I purchase on-line from
Vitalady.com. By the way I did dump from Slim Fast. I must be one of
those people who is sensitive. Stay in touch with your surgeon and contact
him if you have any questions. Also, I was able to learn so much from a
Support Group in my area. I learned from the support group than the
protocol I was handed in the hospital and the 15 minute "talk" I
got from the nutrionist. I was not able to obtain a referral to see the
nutrionist prior to surgery. My medical group wanted me to see an in house
dietitian who knew nothing about Gastric Bypass. Use this web site and get
to a meeting! Every doctor has different protocals and every patient is
different. By hearing and reading different opinions you will find things
that are right for you!
Good Luck on you journey!
— Renee C.
June 3, 2002
Julie, search under ucla bariatric program. That should take you to the
general surgery page. It falls under Clinical Services. Scroll down to
the bottom right hand of the page--"click here for more
information". The diet is
under the Nutrition heading. Good luck!!! Mary
— mary V.
June 3, 2002
I've read the poster's question, as well as the answers thusfar, and I'd
like to bring to light something that I sometimes see here on this site, as
well as with my own patients. There is a tendency to accept without
question information that we are given by our physicians and other health
care professionals, often because we believe that they know best. They
may, or they may not. The field of medicine is continually changing, and
it is impossible for those in the field to keep abreast of all of the
changes in treatment protocols. This is why we must, and I repeat, MUST,
do our own homework, and become COLLABORATORS with our health care
professionals. If you have a physician, dietitian, or whomever, that is
intimidated by your questioning/discussing his or her treatment protocol,
decisions, recommendations, etc, then it it time to find another. Yes, it
IS important to follow our physician's advice, but the reason that we
follow that advice should never be simply because "he/she says
so/knows best." My surgeon has been performing bariatric surgery
since the early 1970's, so he's seen and done it all. But I will tell you
that I have "taken him to school" on several things. Beware,
also, of giving undue weight to a physician's or bariatric program's
"reputation." My personal experience (outside of WLS) bears this
out. An "excellent reputation" is never an excuse for not doing
your own homework. ...OK, I'll step off my soapbox for now... just wanted
to empower all of you to be better health care consumers! JK, RN
— Joya K.
June 3, 2002
Of those who were at least 1 yr post-op who had had dexascans, over 70%
already had bone damage. Tums. They give great blood results, but do not
feed the bones. Slim Fast has about the same nutritional value as a real
coke. Think in terms of what they know. They know what they feed people in
a nursing home or other ailing persons who can afford to gain wt. That
doesn't make it good for them either, of course, but that's what they KNOW
as that is what they teach in school. You don't think I let my 84 y/o
father take either one, do you?
— vitalady
Click Here to Return