Question:
I know it's been said that we will not absorb coral calcium as well as citrate, but
will we get the same benefits from citrate as someone else would from the coral calcium? Some of the calcium claims are pretty impressive, but is it only coral calcium that supports these claims? — Jennifer W. (posted on January 20, 2003)
January 20, 2003
it is my understanding that it is calcuim carbonate (such as in tums and
most pills) that we do not absorb, that calcium citrate we do absorb
better. however there seems to ba a lot of varying information out there on
this issue.
— janetc00
January 20, 2003
To the best of my understanding it is not the absorption of the coral
calcium that is the problem, but the amount you have to take. This product
seems to be labeled in a misleading fashion, showing 1200 mg of coral
calcium per dose BUT of that only abou 200 mg is elemental calcium. So to
get your 1000+ mg a day, you'd have to take 5 doses. I am not sure why they
can get away with that, but it makes me suspicious of the whole thing. I
just take calcium citrate because I KNOW I absorb it and there are no
shenanigans.
— ctyst
January 20, 2003
It is DEFINITELY calcium citrate that we are REQUIRED to take twice daily.
I am not sure about the coral calcium. I have not heard anything about
that. Just an fyi darlin.
— Egyptianeyesdiva
January 20, 2003
hiya. we have a lady in our wls support group who just graduated college
with a degree in nutrition. she says that coral calcium = calcium
carbonate. i have not had time to research the issue.
i take a liquid calcium with magnesium and vitamin d (yes its citrate) and
am happy with it.
good luck,
kate
www.geocities.com/katebme2002
— jkb
Click Here to Return