Question:
Has anyone had

At final pre-surgery appt., Dr. said I had been "chosen" to have lap RNY performed "robotically". He said they choose patients randomly for this type of lap. How experimental is it? Has anyone had it performed and if so, what were your results? (Recovery time, complications, etc.)    — K W. (posted on June 25, 2003)

June 25, 2003
I haven't heard about that, but let me say that if you're not comfortable with it, tell your doctor to "unchoose" you for that. I can't believe that he would make that decision without talking to you about it first. I also would talk to him about the risks, etc.
   — Cheryl M.

June 25, 2003
I've read about this somewhere in the last month or so but can't remember where since I usually do at least an hour of research a day. You may want to do a search on the web. Like the other poster I encourage you to pull the plug on the doc's plan if you aren't comfortable. I know I wouldn't be.
   — A M.

June 25, 2003
http://www.fda.gov/bbs/topics/NEWS/NEW00732.html
   — [Deactivated Member]

June 25, 2003
please note, unles there is a REALLY new device out there that I am un aware of, it isn't the robot actually "doing" the surgery. What it is is a robotic arm, that is controlled by your surgeon, to assist with the surgery. I would definately talk with your surgeon so that you have more understanding and a higher comfort level wiht using this robotic arm.
   — Vicki L.

June 26, 2003
Dear "Chosen One" LOL- The first thing that came to my mind was if this procedure is somewhat experimental, I would think you'd need insurance ok for it. I keep reading that people aren't approved for things (like DS) because it's experimental. Wouldn't want you to be stuck with the robotic portion of your bill after surgery. And my personal feelings about your surgeon chosing this without asking you- I think it's disprespectful to you. Why doesn't he ask all of his patients and let them decide? I'm sure some of them would be ok with it. Good Luck :o)
   — Mea A.

June 26, 2003
your choice of words "He said they choose patients randomly for this type of lap" is a red flag... this sounds like a phase 2 or 3 study. and, as such, you are NOT obligated to participate. in fact, if this IS the case, your doctor is treading a fine ethical line. as a doctor, his responsibility is to YOU.... as a researcher, his responsibility is to collecting results, and ultimately to the manufacturer. also, btw, since no insurance will cover ANY of the costs relating to an experimental procedure, this could be a very costly issue for you. i would wonder about the wording of the informed consent form....especially the section which specifically deals with liability, after-care/emergency treatment, and financial compensation.... meaning, WHO pays for the hospital bills IF you suffer ANY complications? WHO pays for after-care IF (or when) any complication occurs, and WHO provides that care? and, (in the worst case scenario) IF 'something' happens.... have you waived your rights to sue?? you have the right to(and all researchers have the OBLIGATION to give you) the choice to participate. they also have the OBLIGATION to educate you, on the particular procedure, including any and all possible/probable effects. since this procedure takes longer than a 'standard' procedure, i don't see what direct benefit you would enjoy, by participating.
   — tuxedoll