Atkins and Low Carb Weight Loss

Groups » Atkins and Low Carb ... » Discussion » Do you count calori...

Do you count calories???

snowbaby
on 2/9/11 2:32 am - Durango, CO
This is what I read today on Atkins.com - I'm wondering what your thoughts are on this -

Q. Do I need to count calories if I’m counting carbs on Atkins?

A. Usually no, but occasionally yes. Because the Atkins Diet doesn’t require you to count calories when you begin the program, many people mistakenly assume calories don’t count. Even if you eat the low-carb way, you can still consume too many calories, which will definitely stall—or halt—weight loss. Instead, as long as you concentrate on eating the right foods, including protein, natural fats and plenty of foundation vegetables, your appetite should take care of itself and there should be no need to count calories. If you’re losing nicely, don’t worry about calories, but if you aren’t it’s probably time for a reality check.

Q. Are there any studies to back up the caloric advantage of a low-carb diet?

A. In a brilliant study done a few years ago at Harvard University, Dr. Penelope Greene put participants on three different diets. Group 1 received 1,500 calories of low-fat food; Group 2 got 1,800 calories of low-carb food. The result was that Group 2—the low-carb, higher-calorie dieters—lost more weight than the individuals in Group 1, who consumed fewer calories. There’s that caloric advantage. But listen up: there was also a Group 3, in which people also got low-carb food and the same number of calories that Group 1 people got: 1,500 calories. Group 3—the low-cal, low-carb group—lost the most amount of weight of all!

The point is: calories aren’t the whole story—but they do matter. If you’re stuck at a plateau and have stopped losing weight on your low-carb plan, maybe it’s time to see just how much food you’re actually consuming. Women should shoot for a minimum range of 1,500 to 1,800 calories a day, while men should aim for 1,800 to 2,200, and adjust from there. Eat a little less if you’re not losing weight, but avoid the starvation mode of too few calories. If you’re accustomed to counting calories, you’ll know what your range is.


      Sue 

Bichon Mom2 Oval Sticker


        
MSW will not settle
on 2/9/11 8:19 am
For me, counting calories is a must.  I manage my calorie deficit daily.  No "expert" calorie recommendation works consistently for me.  I maintain a deficit in the range of a 1-3 lb per week loss or I ensure I'm within my maintenance range.  Each week and each month, I check that my calorie deficit is where it should be. 

                   MSW   Roux-En-Y Gastric Bypass: Eat sensibly & enjoy moderation  

 Links:  Are you a compulsive eater?  for help OA meets on-line Keep Coming Back, One Day At a Time  Overeaters Anonymous 

               LV'N MY RNY.  WORKING FOR ME BECAUSE I WORK FOR IT. 

Whacka Doodle
on 2/9/11 10:34 am
 This is such a very good question!

When I'm monitoring my intake, I get about 1700 calories a day to maintain -- not lose-- weight.  But I'm always aware that the big issue is going to be carbohydrates (for me) much more than calories.  I have found that if I am starved to distraction in the evening, and really feel I have to eat something, then a tablespoon of peanut butter doesn't do any harm. 

For what it's worth, though I do count calories (my tracking program does that without my asking), I sort of wish I could stop.  I suspect that I tend to eat UP to my requirement, rather than feed naturally, which is when I actually lose weight.  At this point,  I only have about ten pounds left to go, and they are coming off at the rate of only one or two a month.  

Do you count calories?  Or just carbs?
Interested in low-carb nutrition?  Thinking of trying Atkins? Want to try high-fat and/or high-protein eating?  Whether or not you have had (or are thinking about) WLS   http://www.obesityhelp.com/group/atkins/   


snowbaby
on 2/9/11 12:01 pm - Durango, CO
I count both as well. I'm getting about 1200 calories and less than 20 carbs per day. I've been stalled for about 6 weeks now so I've been tweaking both to see if that'll get things moving again...so far nothing. Frustrating!
      Sue 

Bichon Mom2 Oval Sticker


        
Lee ~
on 2/9/11 1:36 pm - CA
I count both.  I maintain at 800-1000 calories w/10- 20 total carbs and an hour of walking or other exercise.  My body seems to be extremely resistent.  My mind is now resistent to taking me lower than 800 calories.  I find that I'm hungry all the time.

HW: 249   SW: 229 GW: 149 Age: 63 - Body by Sauceda - 12/2011

×