VSG Maintenance Group
Eating to maintain
So I'm 4 pounds from goal and starting to experiment with maintenance eating. It's not a successful experiment, kids. I know how to eat to lose weight. I sure as **** know how to eat to gain weight. Eating to do neither of those things? Yeah, I'm baffled. I need structure!
Do you all still track? Do you just increase calories? Carbs? Help!
Do you all still track? Do you just increase calories? Carbs? Help!
High weight: 276
Lowest weight: 155.2
Currently : 159-164
Couch potato to runner in 18 months!
bunnymom
on 3/23/12 11:03 am, edited 3/23/12 11:04 am
on 3/23/12 11:03 am, edited 3/23/12 11:04 am
You and me both. I am close to my goal and lately have been naturally taking in more calories (around 1100 to 1300) on some days. Amazingly, on those amount of calories, I am still losing weight. So instead of panicking that I was ingesting too many calories all of a sudden (I am near 14 months out), now I am worrying I may keep losing. All I can tell from my tracking is that I still lose because my carbs are under 20, and sometimes are under 10, and I sure lose on those days, no matter what amount of calories I take in or how guilty I feel. Weird. It may be that we'll have to add in some carb grams when we want to lose no more. It is a real mind game at this point, and I agree with you that it is not easy. The old-timers tell us to add in 100 cals per day till you stop losing. I have been doing that this last month, whether I wanted to or not (my capacity just plain increased somewhat), and I am still losing. I think for me, it may be adding in carbs---carefully, so carefully--that will be the determining factor. Good luck. Tell me what you are mulling around in your head too if any answers come to you.
Here is what I do, having been at goal for over a year:
i started out increasing calories by 100 per day and doing that each week or so until I got to where I stopped losing.
I still track all my food, carbs and calories and protein. Still get 70 protein a day. Calories stay under 1200 as that is just all i can do and not gain. I don't have a fixed limit on carbs but I avoid bread, potatoes , rice and pasta and such. most carbs are in fruit, dairy or veggies. Usually about 60 a day.
Maintenance is a lot like weight loss. still weigh everyday and still am very conscious of this stuff. I think i am going to have to do this forever to stay at this weight. I am comfortable with that as I like being thin and don't want to go back and am highly motivated to maintain.
I am not a good exerciser but use a FitBit and try to do some extra walking each day to not be a total slug.
I do eat small servings of sweets at parties or celebrations but keep it really small and don't let it drag me into more sweet eating. so far i am able to do this and hope i can continue. have tried to not make food such a big focus of my life.
thats about it. keep reading this group for good ideas.
Diane
i started out increasing calories by 100 per day and doing that each week or so until I got to where I stopped losing.
I still track all my food, carbs and calories and protein. Still get 70 protein a day. Calories stay under 1200 as that is just all i can do and not gain. I don't have a fixed limit on carbs but I avoid bread, potatoes , rice and pasta and such. most carbs are in fruit, dairy or veggies. Usually about 60 a day.
Maintenance is a lot like weight loss. still weigh everyday and still am very conscious of this stuff. I think i am going to have to do this forever to stay at this weight. I am comfortable with that as I like being thin and don't want to go back and am highly motivated to maintain.
I am not a good exerciser but use a FitBit and try to do some extra walking each day to not be a total slug.
I do eat small servings of sweets at parties or celebrations but keep it really small and don't let it drag me into more sweet eating. so far i am able to do this and hope i can continue. have tried to not make food such a big focus of my life.
thats about it. keep reading this group for good ideas.
Diane
bunnymom
on 3/24/12 12:10 am
on 3/24/12 12:10 am
Thanx Diane!! I think my maintenance plan is going to look alot like your maintenance plan. I will prob add back in fruits, as I have had none since I started. I had to start some Vit C supplementation as I started getting some Scurvy symptoms, if you can believe that. (fissures that don't heal in mucosa, non-healing minor wounds, etc.) crazy, but no fruit for 14 months and I was down on my Vit C. So yeah, will add back in some fruit soon, esp berries, oranges. Thanx for your input. I think 1200 cal will be about my max too.
I went nuts trying different things and eventually went back to what I did to lose weight. Only with more calories, more carbs and more endulgences.
HW - 225 SW - 191 GW - 132 CW - 122
Visit my blog at Fatty Fights Back Become a Fan on Facebook!
Starting BMI 40-ish or less? Join the LightWeights
THats what I'm experimenting with too. I am now in 138 and had originally thought my goal would be 135 then made it 142. I am happy where I am,a d am doing what I had been doing as far as tracking, etc and rating a lot of protein (and protein drinks).
I have added in fruit, more vegetables and whole grains. That seems to be working so far. If I have a treat, I make sure I have tracked it and try to make sure I exercise that day..I do exercise most days for at least 30 minutes.
It is too soon to tell but I feel great! I also weigh daily, go to weigh****chers weekly and track in my fitnesspal and WW site.
Lynn
I have added in fruit, more vegetables and whole grains. That seems to be working so far. If I have a treat, I make sure I have tracked it and try to make sure I exercise that day..I do exercise most days for at least 30 minutes.
It is too soon to tell but I feel great! I also weigh daily, go to weigh****chers weekly and track in my fitnesspal and WW site.
Lynn
I am in the same boat you are. I've been increasing my calories gradually and each time I plateau a few weeks then start losing again. Since I can't eat more I've been using 1% or 2% milk in my shakes, eating nuts and nut butters and more fruits (I ate a lot of veggies during loss but not much fruit).
Don't underestimate the power of healthy fats. They are calorie dense and help you add calories without eating more food.
I also have a serving of frozen yogurt now and then (a serving is 1/2 cup, I measure and eat it out of the measuring cup).
I plan to continue weighing/measuring and tracking indefinitely. On my iPhone it's so easy (I use myfitnesspal) and I hope once I find my maintenance range it'll help me avoid "calorie creep"
Far from an expert, but that's what I'm trying.
Don't underestimate the power of healthy fats. They are calorie dense and help you add calories without eating more food.
I also have a serving of frozen yogurt now and then (a serving is 1/2 cup, I measure and eat it out of the measuring cup).
I plan to continue weighing/measuring and tracking indefinitely. On my iPhone it's so easy (I use myfitnesspal) and I hope once I find my maintenance range it'll help me avoid "calorie creep"
Far from an expert, but that's what I'm trying.
Highest weight: 335 lbs, BMI 50.9
Pre-op weight: 319 lbs, BMI 48.5
Current range: 140-144, BMI 21.3 - 22
175+ lbs lost, maintaining since February 2012