VSG Maintenance Group

Groups » VSG Maintenance Grou... » Discussion » The last step for o...

The last step for obese - removing 80 per cent of their stomach

mini_me_ now
on 11/26/11 8:18 am
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/national/the-last-step-for-obese-removing-80-per-cent-of-their-stomach/story-e6frf7l6-1226207197080


The last step for obese - removing 80 per cent of their stomach

   0 sharon

Sharon Fairbairn with daughter Anabella after having three quarters of her stomach removed. Picture: Ella Pellegrini The Sunday Telegraph

sharon

Before surgery: Sharon on trip to Fraser Island in December 2009. Picture: Ella Pellegrini The Sunday Telegraph

DRASTIC weight loss surgery that involves removing up to 80 per cent of a person's stomach has doctors divided.

Some say it's so risky they won't even perform it while others say patients can lose 30-40kg in a year and can still eat bread and pasta.

The drastic operation called sleeve gastrectomy - or "sleeving" - can result in serious complications and is 10 times more dangerous than lap-banding.

Once the outer part of the stomach is completely removed via keyhole technique, the remaining piece of the stomach is stapled to form a banana-shaped tube.

This reduces its holding capacity from about 2L to 100mL, increasing stomach pressure after eating small portions to make people feel full more quickly.

One of Australia's "sleeving" pioneers, Dr Michael Talbot, said the most serious complication is gastric fluid leaking from the staple line causing serious infection that can result in a month-long hospital stay or even death.

 

Lap-banding is safer and Dr Talbot warned that sleeving should only be performed on the morbidly obese in need of rapid weight loss.

"That risk varies from 0.5 per cent to 3 per cent depending on the centre where the surgery is occurring and the experience of the surgeon," said Dr Talbot, an upper gastro intestinal surgeon at St George Public and Pri- vate Hospitals.

"If there are several hundred cases a year, statistically speaking it will happen. Whereas the risk of significant complications of a similar magnitude is one in 1000 or less with the gastric band."

Dr Talbot said on average, patients lose 60 per cent of the extra weight they carry, or 30-40kg over 12 months.

Dr Ali Zarrouk, who performed the first sleeve gastrectomy at Campbelltown Private Hospital in September, said

patients who have a sleeve gastrectomy lose weight immediately and don't have to avoid pasta, bread or meat.

Single mother Sharon Fairbairn weighed 105kg and struggled to run after her seven-year-old daughter, Anabella, when she had the radical operation in September last year. "I wish I'd done it 10 years ago," she said.

After Medicare cover, out-of-pocket expenses range between $3000 and $7000 for the procedure.

But surgeon and associate professor at the Centre for Obesity Research and Education Wendy Brown refuses to perform sleeve gastrectomies as the surgery is too risky.

"With a (gastric) band or even a (gastric) bypass you can actually do another operation if you find out you've done it wrong, but with a sleeve gastrectomy you've taken a patient's stomach out," she said. "They can't grow another stomach."

 

 


Maintaining Cindy
on 11/26/11 11:59 am
  Frick!!  So untrue, so mis-informed...  such bad press!!    What a shame... 

   

MacMadame
on 11/26/11 2:56 pm - Northern, CA
 Sigh.

HW - 225 SW - 191 GW - 132 CW - 122
Visit my blog at Fatty Fights Back      Become a Fan on Facebook!
Starting BMI 40-ish or less? Join the LightWeights

bunnymom
on 11/27/11 1:34 am, edited 11/27/11 1:35 am
Oh yeah, just keep piling on the bread and pasta! Geesh!  They also completely ignore how much work we have to put in to lose every pound.
Bunnymom            
Jackie
Multiplepetmom

on 11/27/11 2:10 am
 oh sure, a band is SO much safer  

once upon a time I had a group to talk about Binge Eating Disorder, and later one about Clean Eating.

PM me if you are interested in either of these.

 size 8, life is great
 

loverofcats
on 11/27/11 2:23 am
What a wonderful example of a poorly researched article. Sigh. Nothing about how people have to work hard everyday to maintain weight loss and how vital exercise is to the entire process. Nothing about how people have lived for many years with partial and total gastrectomies and that this procedure has been performed for at least 50 years for people with ulcers and stomach cancer. Nothing about the horrific complications from lap bands and bypass procedures. The article is total garbage.


Gail
     "          
 LW-Apple-Gold-Small.jpg image by PlicketyCat
    
infodiva808
on 11/27/11 7:08 am
What a poorly informed reporter!
            
Jenijeni
on 11/27/11 7:47 pm


       

HW: 250 SW: 224 GW: 135 CW: 124

mimikay
on 11/28/11 4:35 am
Glad I live in the US! What a pity for the Aussies...
  Kay       HW 219/SW 212/CW 134              
Seiren
on 11/28/11 4:41 am - The Colony, TX
 My support group leader said something I still think about:
"Why would you ever want back the part of your stomach that made you fat?"

Hah, I would never want that back.

Also, not to go against what you guys went through, but I lost my weight with ease. It's only the last 20lbs that are having to put lots of work in. OF course I did follow the rules (for the most part), but it came easy to me.

   

×