Profile COMPLETE CHANGE - HELP

Okay, so I want to know HOW I can change my profile name. Well, I already know how to do that, but this is what I want. I've changed my name before from my real life name to my on line name here at OH. However, you can still google me and go straight to my "altered profile" - I currently have it off line so Son of Satan can't google me. What I did was I opened a (okay I tried to but it denied me) new account, but because I have the same email address as my profile currently, it won't let me advance. Suggestions, comments - HELP!!!

Set up a different email account for the new profile - a yahoo or hotmail acct. That's my only suggestion. Patty