Best protein shake that doesn't taste like a protein shake

brownblonde
on 2/12/15 5:10 am

Hi all.  I'm trying to get back up on the wagon.  I think my surgeon preferred that we eat solid food after the initial stage (and I'm waaaayy past that), but sometimes life, or laziness, or whathaveyou gets in the way.  I also know I'm not getting enough protein.  So I think for a little while I'm at least going to keep a stock of protein shakes on hand for breakfast or a quick meal if I have to.  I hate the filmy residue from protein shakes although I suppose that's unavoidable.  What I'm looking for may well not exist, but ideally I want a shake that is low carb, high protein, doesn't taste (or for that matter smell) icky, and maybe is ready-to-drink variety.  Thanks in advance

        
Gwen M.
on 2/12/15 5:20 am
VSG on 03/13/14

Well, the thing is that it's all a matter of personal opinion.  So I can tell you the shake I love, but it might not float your boat.  

I've been using Optimum Nutrition Double Rich Chocolate (which I order in alb tubs from Amazon) and I mix that with unsweetened original almond milk in a Blender Bottle (I order those from Amazon too).  I love them.  

VSG with Dr. Salameh - 3/13/2014
Diagnosed with Binge Eating Disorder and started Vyvanse - 7/22/2016
Reconstructive Surgeries with Dr. Michaels - 6/5/2017 (LBL & brachioplasty), 8/14/2017 (UBL & mastopexy), 11/6/2017 (medial leg lift)

Age 42 Height 5'4" HW 319 (1/3/2014) SW 293 (3/13/2014) CW 149 (7/16/2017)
Next Goal 145 - normal BMI | Total Weight Lost 170

TrendWeight | Food Blog (sort of functional) | Journal (down for maintenance)

emelar
on 2/12/15 5:20 am - TX

Premier Protein RTD.  I heat one up most mornings.  Tastes as close to hot chocolate as a protein drink is gonna get.  30g of protein, 160 calories (I think), don't remember the carb count.

But you know protein drinks are personal.  What I love, you might hate!  I've seen Premier in several grocery stores in 4-packs, so you can try them out before you commit to a whole case.

GeekMonster, Insolent Hag
on 2/12/15 7:55 am - CA
VSG on 12/19/13

^^^  Premier Protein RTD in chocolate.  They have 5g of carbs.  

I drink one every morning with a shot of Miralax.  I don't mind them, but they're not a milkshake from In-N-Out.  I drink them because of the high level of protein.  They have vanilla and strawberry cream flavors, but I keep coming back to chocolate.  It doesn't burn me out.

As everyone says, your taste buds may vary.

"Oderint Dum Metuant"    Discover the joys of the Five Day Meat Test!

Height:  5'-7"  HW: 449  SW: 392  GW: 179  CW: 220

GooseGirl
on 2/12/15 5:40 am
VSG on 10/30/14 with

My favorite shake is made by BPI Sports and the flavor is Vanilla Caramel. I also really like Cellucor's Cinnamon Swirl and Cookies and Cream. If you buy them at GNC and don't like it then you have the ability to return them (even opened). 

BPI Sports #s: 126 cal, 2 g fat, 3g Total Carbs, 25g Protein

Cellucor #s: 130 cal, 1.5 g fat, 4g Total Carbs, 25g Protein

 

    

    

JoeyJo
on 2/12/15 5:41 am - NJ

I prefer Quest protein bars to drinking shakes.  Lots of protein and fiber with low carbs.

 

PrayMore
on 2/12/15 5:44 am

My favorite shake is Celebrate vanilla bean meal replacement protein shake, mixed with light vanilla soy milk and ice in a blender. I order the tubs from the Celebrate Web site. Their chocolate flavor is good, too. I thought these were the least 'whey-ish' when I tried different brands.

I also enjoy Muscle Milk chocolate (light when available) if I need to grab something at a convenient store.

  

5'6", VSG on Dec. 2

    

KeishaLeigh
on 2/12/15 5:49 am - NC
VSG on 02/24/15 with

 I have found some flavors that I enjoy in Syntrax. They are more thin and fruity. I went to Nashua Nutrition to order. You can get samples of a lot of the different brands for about $2 each. I did this so I didn't waste money on large tubs I wouldn't ever drink.

38 y.o. 5'7" HW 347 SW 332 M1 -22 M2 -18 M3 -19 M4 -9 M5 -18 M6 -11 M7 -13 M8-9 M9 -7 M10 -8 M11 -5 M12 -1 M13 -9 M14 -0 

BrendaRae
on 2/12/15 10:35 am
VSG on 01/13/15

I LOVE the Syntrax variety pack! Had the cherry twist this morning! Make with skim milk fOr 31 gms of protein!😀

      

        

    

    
Stacy_WLS
on 2/12/15 6:37 am

Chike!

VSG: 12/12/13, LBL, small TL, BL/BA: 11/7/14 Twins 12/9/18 HW after Twins 260. 5'10 37 years old - Stacy_WLS (MFP)

Most Active
×