Is Stevia a Better Choice?

Corrie33
on 2/11/16 11:25 am, edited 2/11/16 12:08 pm
RNY on 02/09/15

I'm concerned about the artificial sweeteners in the beverages I drink now.  My Crystal Lite, Diet Snapple, Protein Drinks and sugar free syrups all have either Aspartame or Sucralose, and so does the Equal or Splenda I use in my hot tea.   I try to ge****er in, but it still doesn't fully sit well with me. 

Anyone know if there are any benefits to buying Stevia instead?  Is it better for you?  Does it metabolize the same?  Does it still taste good?

Thanks!

 

GOAL REACHED! 170 lbs lost...

RNY: 2/9/15 (age 52), Ht-5'9" HW=304, SW=292, GW=155, LW=134, CW=147

Mo.1 -29lbs Mo.2 -18lbs Mo.3 -13lbs Mo.4 -11lbs Mo.5 - 14lbs Mo.6 - 10lbs Mo. 7 -11lbs Mo. 8 -9.4lbs

Deanna798
on 2/11/16 11:37 am
RNY on 08/04/15

I did a little research because my aunt told me last summer that stevia was bad for you.  The side effects taht go with Stevia are making you feel full and lowering blood sugar.  At the time I was pre-op and thought, perfect side effects!  the problem with Stevia is I don't like the way it tastes. I've used the liquid and didn't care for it.

I can't drink straigh****er either, so I stick with sucralose almost exclusively.  But if you like Stevia and don't have any issues with low blood sugar, i don't see why it would hurt you.  

Please note, I am not a doctor, so if you have major concerns ask your doctor! 

Age: 44 | Height: 5' 3" | Starting January 2015: 291 | RNY 8/4/15 with Dr. Arthur Carlin| Goal: 150

Listen to advice and accept discipline, and at the end you will be counted among the wise. ~Proverbs 19:20

Corrie33
on 2/11/16 12:07 pm
RNY on 02/09/15

Thanks for that, Deanna - great tips.  I think I'll put it on the grocery list and see if I like it or not.    

 

Anyone else have any thoughts about Stevia vs. Sucrolose?  (I try to avoid Aspartame whenever I can.)

GOAL REACHED! 170 lbs lost...

RNY: 2/9/15 (age 52), Ht-5'9" HW=304, SW=292, GW=155, LW=134, CW=147

Mo.1 -29lbs Mo.2 -18lbs Mo.3 -13lbs Mo.4 -11lbs Mo.5 - 14lbs Mo.6 - 10lbs Mo. 7 -11lbs Mo. 8 -9.4lbs

Flaxie
on 2/12/16 8:47 pm
RNY on 03/15/16

Hello, I bought the stevia liquid and the granules, I think the granules taste much better.

Cheers flaxie

NYMom222
on 2/12/16 8:14 am
RNY on 07/23/14

Forgot to add, if you want a protein powder with Stevia, there is Jay Robb which I like, but I like this one better: BodyLogix Natural Whey

They sell it at GNC and Walgreens. When Walgreens puts it on sale it is like $22 for a big container. Walgreens regular price is cheaper than GNC too. They also make one that is all isolate, but you need to buy that on the internet.

Cynthia 5'11" RNY 7/23/2014

Goal reached 17 months. 220lb Weight Loss
Plastic Surgery Dr. Joseph Michaels - LBL and Hernia Repair 2/29/16, Arm Lift, BL, 5/2/16, Leg Lift 7/25/16

#lifeisanadventure #fightthegoodfight #noregrets

Save

Save

NYMom222
on 2/11/16 12:21 pm
RNY on 07/23/14

Ah stevia.... I have tried many brands in the name of science...hahahaha. Skinny girl has a liquid one you can get in a lot of places that I think is pretty good. Powdered this is the best I have found so far- Nu Naturals, GNC or the Internet(don't care for their liquid) NuNaturals

Just started using Sucralose again... bought the liquid, because even though the powdered is zero calories, it does have carbs and it can add up if you use multiples.... anyway according to the low-carb websites ... SucraDrops

The one I use for baking is Swerve. It is pricey, I can buy it locally or on Amazon. They have a confectioner's sugar one I buy on Amazon.
Swerve I pay $7-9 at my local Stop n' Shop in the health food section (depending if it is on sale)

Lastly for the Brown Sugar taste I use Brown Sugar Truvia. It does have some molasses in it. But it is moist like real brown sugar not Granular.
Brown Sugar Truvia I also buy that in my local Stop n'Shop by other sweeteners and it is cheaper than that Amazon price.

So is it really healthier? I don't know...but I figure it is healthier to be thinner, so whatever works.

 

 

Cynthia 5'11" RNY 7/23/2014

Goal reached 17 months. 220lb Weight Loss
Plastic Surgery Dr. Joseph Michaels - LBL and Hernia Repair 2/29/16, Arm Lift, BL, 5/2/16, Leg Lift 7/25/16

#lifeisanadventure #fightthegoodfight #noregrets

Save

Save

Maria27
on 2/11/16 3:16 pm - Chicago, IL
RNY on 03/17/15

My dietitian recommends Stevia and claims it is a better choice, but I don't have a scientific explanation for you. I don't mind the taste. You just have to be really careful because using too much makes it taste bitter. I try to limit my sucralose because high levels can be harmful, but there is no real data showing that low levels are harmful, just a lot of speculation.

Height: 5'5" HW: 290 Consultation Weight: 276 SW: 257 CW: 132

Corrie33
on 2/11/16 3:49 pm
RNY on 02/09/15

Thanks Maria!

GOAL REACHED! 170 lbs lost...

RNY: 2/9/15 (age 52), Ht-5'9" HW=304, SW=292, GW=155, LW=134, CW=147

Mo.1 -29lbs Mo.2 -18lbs Mo.3 -13lbs Mo.4 -11lbs Mo.5 - 14lbs Mo.6 - 10lbs Mo. 7 -11lbs Mo. 8 -9.4lbs

seattledeb
on 2/11/16 5:20 pm

It tastes very bitter to me. My suggestion is go to a kinda health food coffee shop and pick up a drink and try it. 

shirleym
on 2/11/16 6:45 pm - Springfield, OR

Unfortunately, to me stevia leaves a taste of licorice and I hate licorice.

All time high weight - 366 lbs; initial loss 180 lbs

regained to 318 lbs; got back on track middle of Jan. 2015

current weight 172.4

Most Active
What's on your (photo) Friday menu?
Ymaliz · 41 replies · 410 views
What's on Your Tuesday Menu
White Dove · 10 replies · 185 views
Whats On Your Thursday Menu
White Dove · 8 replies · 109 views
What's on your Monday menu?
Ymaliz · 7 replies · 159 views
What's on your Wednesday Menu
Mkess · 4 replies · 104 views
Recent Topics
Whats On Your Thursday Menu
White Dove · 8 replies · 109 views
What's on your Wednesday Menu
Mkess · 4 replies · 104 views
What's on Your Tuesday Menu
White Dove · 10 replies · 185 views
What's on your Monday menu?
Ymaliz · 7 replies · 159 views
×