Carbs.....how many??
I'm nearly 7 years out so I should have this eating down, but apparently I don't. During one of my post-op visits, the dietician told me I should have a minimum of 130 good carbs daily just for the brain to function. That just doesn't work for me. I have a 12 lbs. regain and just can't seem to get rid of those lbs. The last 6 months I've been on a temp job and sitting all day. I exercise but not regularly and I know I need to exercise daily. This job will end May 28th and I plan to take the summer off so no excuses for not exercising.
What should the limit for carbs be to lose weight? Why doesn't a plan for 1,200 calories where you are eating healthy but including fruit and some starches not work? I tried it and didn't work for me. Do our new stomachs just not process carbs, healthy or not, like a normal stomach?
I can't allow myself to fail and gain more weight. I was on some weight loss program for 35 years before surgery and nothing worked. I know RNY works and I want to work it to my advantage.
~Jo~
RNY: July 8, 2008
Dr. John Price
Kansas City, MO
As a general rule I allowed myself a limit of 100 grams of carbs a day, tried to keep it around 50 but there are a lot of carbs in things like Greek yogurt so I wasn't always able to.
For maintenance I don't really count carbs. I watch them and avoid really high carb things on a regular basis but I avoid refined carbs like sugar and flour. For me where the carbs from are as important as how many I consume.
Almost everything I eat that has carbs are in their natural state, like fruits and vegetables, and not refined or processed.
As someone recently posted, not all carbs are alike.
WLS 10/28/2002 Revision 7/23/2010
High Weight (2002) 240 Revision Weight (2010) 220 Current Weight 115.
on 5/8/15 2:28 pm - WI
I'm nearly 7 years out so I should have this eating down, but apparently I don't. During one of my post-op visits, the dietician told me I should have a minimum of 130 good carbs daily just for the brain to function. That just doesn't work for me. I have a 12 lbs. regain and just can't seem to get rid of those lbs. The last 6 months I've been on a temp job and sitting all day. I exercise but not regularly and I know I need to exercise daily. This job will end May 28th and I plan to take the summer off so no excuses for not exercising.
What should the limit for carbs be to lose weight? Why doesn't a plan for 1,200 calories where you are eating healthy but including fruit and some starches not work? I tried it and didn't work for me. Do our new stomachs just not process carbs, healthy or not, like a normal stomach?
I can't allow myself to fail and gain more weight. I was on some weight loss program for 35 years before surgery and nothing worked. I know RNY works and I want to work it to my advantage.
Your dietician is wrong. You don't actually need to eat ANY carbs at all, though zero carbs is incredibly difficult. Your brain does need a very small amount of carbs, but your body can synthesize what it needs from protein and fat.
Protein and fats are essential because your body cannot produce them, they must be eaten. Carbs are not essential at all.
6'3" tall, male.
Highest weight was 475. RNY on 08/21/12. Current weight: 198.
M1 -24; M2 -21; M3 -19; M4 -21; M5 -13; M6 -21; M7 -10; M8 -16; M9 -10; M10 -8; M11 -6; M12 -5.
At close to 6 years out, I am "allowed" 80-100 gm. of carbs but feel my best when I don't eat that many. My carbs generally come from fruit, veggies, and "whole" sources - I don't use dairy, and steer clear of rice and pasta. I have an occasional baked sweet potato and an occasional dinner roll, but that's about it.
I eat cheese and Greek yogurt. I eat plain Greek yogurt daily for awhile then I quit eating it for awhile. Sometimes I add a few blackberries. Fage is my favorite brand. Don't like cottage cheese at all. I make a salad with cottage cheese, sugar free Jello and Cool Whip that I really like. I have a protein check daily, sometimes two. I add a serving of Sytrax Roadside Lemonade to water and sip on that. Good way to get protein. I do add Crystal Lite to that.
~Jo~
RNY: July 8, 2008
Dr. John Price
Kansas City, MO
I don't eat those things but please be clear - it's a personal choice. I did use dairy for a long time but slowly found myself consuming less and less until it was almost nothing. The last hold out was cheese - which my dietitian says is probably too high in fat for me to use very often. Cheese stick**** me as way too salty for some reason.
I am a Lacto-Ovo Vegetarian. I eat simple carbohydrate dairy products that are no fat or low fat. I eat eggs. I eat complex carbohydrate beans. I also eat simple carbohydrate fruit and complex carbohydrate vegetables and whole grains. I do not count daily carb grams. All carbs are not created equal. I definitely refrain from eating refined carbs.