confused
~Kim~
~Not to make it more confusing..but I beg to differ about the comment that the band is the LEAST EFFECTIVE of the WLS~
You can beg to differ all you want but that doesn't change the stats. And no matter what stats you look at, the band ALWAYS comes up at the bottom when comparing WLS's!
Hislady is not lying. It is what it is.
While these statistics “may" be true (I ALWAYS question research results because many times they discard certain results to bolster their hypostasis), look at the time line this was conducted: 1990 to 2002.
A lot has changed in 10 years.
Let’s see the stats of a newer/recent comparison, whi*****luds ALL bariatric operations.
Tom
“Nothing I will ever eat will give me the feeling I get as when I lose weight” The views expressed are based on my own experiences - and should NOT BE FOLLOWED IN LIEU OF DOCTOR’S ADVICE/INSTRUCTIONS. Only your Doctor knows your condition, and make sure you talk to them before making any changes to your diet
Maria,
You should know me, I never have any issues when someone “speaks from the heart with their experiences" when it comes to band issues. I feel this is sooooo important, especially when someone is thinking about it. They need to know it’s not all rainbows and unicorns.
I also have no issues if someone post medical facts when it comes to any of these operations, especially the band.
What I am questioning is THIS chart. (A) the information is obtained from 1990 to 2002. 2002 is 10 years ago, and I think (know) the bariatric world has changed in the last 10 years. IMHO this information is outdated, and may be misleading. It would be like me posting data obtained in the late 80’s – early 90’s about bypass success, when during that time many bypass patients were either failing or dying. (B) In a “previous" life I was a writer, and I helped write-up research articles. I’ve know what goes on “behind the scenes" when it comes to research articles. I’ve seen how certain outcomes are dismissed or omitted, because the data does not reinforce the original theory. So no matter what I see, I always question "how reliable is this information" (both pro and con).
Plus this “chart" only shows band; bypass and d/s. Where is the (updated) quantified data on all other operations, such as: BIB (BioEnterics Intragastric Balloon); Biliopancreatic Diversion; Fobi Pouch; MGB (mini-gastric bypass); VGB (vertical banded gastroplasty); VSG (vertical sleeve gastrectomy) – just to name a few? Once I see the stats of all these operations, then I will be more inclined to say OPERATION Z is best choice, and OPERATION Q is the worst.
Tom
“Nothing I will ever eat will give me the feeling I get as when I lose weight” The views expressed are based on my own experiences - and should NOT BE FOLLOWED IN LIEU OF DOCTOR’S ADVICE/INSTRUCTIONS. Only your Doctor knows your condition, and make sure you talk to them before making any changes to your diet
Tom you're probably my favorite cheerleader. I would pop on the Realize forum from time to time and always noticed it was a much more supportive place than the lap-band forum. You do a good job being neutral for the most part.
As far as those stats. That is just one study, but I have never seen ANY study where the band did not come out in LAST place of all the 4 major WLS's. Have you???
It's like the difference between Coke and Pepsi; Honda or Toyota ... Band size, port "shape", port attachment & how it "attaches" is the only difference.
I have been a very successful band person, but will admit it's not easy. As you know, NONE OF THESE operations are 100% success or failures. Each person's results will be different.
Research Research Research before you decide which way to go.
But know no matter what you decide, I will be here to help you
Tom
“Nothing I will ever eat will give me the feeling I get as when I lose weight” The views expressed are based on my own experiences - and should NOT BE FOLLOWED IN LIEU OF DOCTOR’S ADVICE/INSTRUCTIONS. Only your Doctor knows your condition, and make sure you talk to them before making any changes to your diet
Hugs and blessings ~~~ Vivian
GOD GRANT ME THE SERENITY TO ACCEPT THE THINGS I CAN NOT CHANGE; COURAGE TO CHANGE THE THINGS THAT I CAN; AND THE WISDOM TO KNOW THE DIFFERENCE !!!! THIS IS MY DAILY PRAYER.
Vivian Prouty Obesity Help Support Group Coach "LOSE IT 4 LIFE"
