Difference betweed Dollar store Pregnancy test and First Response

jessann5
on 3/22/13 12:55 am - Kansas City, KS

So my lurking has raised a question, I was wondering what the difference was between a test from the dollar store and a more expensive test like First Response or Clear Blue Easy.

I have one of both ready for my two week waiting period to be over. I bought the Dollar store one because, hey it was $1 and I could not believe they sold them there.

But then the crazy took over and I thought I had better get a higher quality test so I bought a first resonse.....ummm ya $14 for two test sticks.

So girls what's the difference?

 RNY 1/29/08
Pre: BMI 47.6 wt 279
Current: BMI 24.9 wt 146
total pounds lost: 133

LogansMommy
on 3/22/13 2:26 am - Marietta, GA

http://www.peeonastick.com/

This is the expert on Peeing on a Stick!

Cheri

 

Mara005
on 3/22/13 8:23 am

I bought a bunch of internet cheapies (like this- http://www.amazon.com/Wondfo-Pregnancy-Test-Strips-25-count/dp/B0002YIQEQ/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1363990683&sr=8-1&keywords=wondfo+pregnancy+test) and got my BFP on 11 dpo. While the expensive ones are nice, they aren't worth it if you're a POAS addict. Also, walmart has ones for $.88 that work well too.

That said, I had some digitals and it was great to see "pregnant" pop up, but that was only after I had a faint line on a cheapie.

Lap Band w/ Plication - Oct. 4, 2012  SW:318 CW:241 GW:175

 

Alice P.
on 3/22/13 8:53 am

My guess is there is very little difference!  When I had a natural miscarriage 12 yrs ago at 13 weeks--I was told to take a test a month after to confirm there were no remaining products in me--I refused to buy an expensive one and bought the cheapest I could find and it came up positive so OB made me come directly in for a beta level blood test--it was 25 which is like 1 day pregnant so I think they work well and that was 12 yrs ago!!!!!!!!!

 HW 278 SW 259 GW 170 CW 142 Ht 5ft 6

   

michellerayne
on 3/22/13 9:27 am
RNY on 09/19/12

There are a lot of first response advocates out there, but I don't really know if there is a difference.  I've used both.  With my current pregnancy I used a Walmart one which was around 4 bucks, and when it showed up positive I moved to a digital test just so I could see the pregnant or not pregnant result.  I didn't have to guess with lines and such.  Good luck, I think if you're pregnant and you don't test too early you'll get a positive result regardless of the brand.  Again, good luck I hope the 2WW goes fast for you :)

Paula622
on 3/22/13 12:44 pm

I used to be a big advocate of the dollar store tests, but I've recently changed my tune.  They're definitely not as sensitive as the First Response, so if you're looking for early testing, FR is probably going to catch it sooner.  I recently had a miscarriage and had my levels tested while taking dollar store tests to check for lingering lines.  When my HCG was 80, I got a test line that could only be seen when I held it up to the light, squinted at, etc.  As my hormones got down to 40, there was no test line left on the dollar store test.  First Response can pick up HCG around 20. 

~ Paula
219/185/127/121/119
HW/SW/Original Goal/CW/New Goal 
Post WLS baby, born 11/10/11 and 3/20/14
 
      

T. Deeds
on 3/25/13 2:04 am
I really liked the digital ones, because there was no interpreting the results. They clearly say "Pregnant" or "Not Pregnant."

               
    

BIGGY
on 4/3/13 12:30 am - Tulsa, OK
VSG on 07/24/12

I don't know what the difference is. I did get a BFP at 3 weeks  pregnant with the dollar tree test.

HW:375 (04/02/12) 
SW:339 (07/
24/12)
CW:244 (11/13/14)

    

    

teenuh
on 4/5/13 5:53 am - Canada

I got a very clear + on a ebay cheapie one and my HCG was under 25.....save your pennies and buy a bulk back off ebay or dollar store ones :) 

 HW:369lbs  SW: 296.4lbs CW: 201lbs GW: 180
Surgery: VSG  Date: January 9, 2013
M1 - 24lbs M2 - 11lbs M3- 13.6lbs M4 -13.4lbs m5 -12lbs m6 -12lbs m7- 7lbs

        

Most Active
Recent Topics
Post Preganancy Weight Gain
nko_88 · 3 replies · 1404 views
Procare prenatal vitamins?
liz52408 · 2 replies · 947 views
Glucose test
marianacc · 9 replies · 1445 views
×