I had open and I was up and around in no time at all.  All people are different in recovery time though. I opted for open because I liked and felt comfortable with my surgeon and it was less time I was on the table which was alright with me since I have asthma and he didnt want me on my back for along period of time but having 300+ lbs is alot to be bearing on your back.  But its what you feel comfortable with and your intuition will let you know. I wouldnt change my decision for all the money in the world. I healed very well with no signs of infection my scar isnt that bad anymore and Im glad I had opened.  BUT not everyone is the same just remember that just because this procedure went well with me doesnt mean it well for someone else. Go with what you want and feel is best...I based my decision on the surgeon and what he performed and went from there!! Good luck with your choice!!