Atkins/Zone/South Beach/WW/LF

arruncomic
on 9/9/08 8:51 am

Which diet have you found to be the most effective?

I've always tried Low Fat-High Protein, but I'm thinking of switching. I feel I need to try something new.

I appreciate any input.

Future Legend
on 9/9/08 9:08 am - SC
I'm doing low carb/high fat....   and this is the first time I've been truly successful (other than the starving for the 10 lb thing when I was younger).
JerseyGirl1969
on 9/9/08 9:17 am - Milford, NJ

atkins (DANDR)
high fat, mod protein, low low low carb

I eat a lot of calories, enjoy food, and am never hungry.

 

what could be better?


arruncomic
on 9/9/08 9:36 am
Have you had any problems or side effects from Atkins?
Future Legend
on 9/9/08 9:56 am - SC
SURE.. I've had side effects..

My blood sugar is now completely in control and was in control during the first week of low carb - I haven't taken even 1 shot of insulin since I started doing this.  My A1C went from a 12 to 5.9.

My triglycerides went from 650 down to 169

My blood pressure is down to 114/78

After the first 5 days, I got a boost in energy that I didn't know existed!

My resting heart rate dropped from over 100 to high 70's

I can walk!  Which is more than I can say for BEFORE Atkins/low carb.  Wait.. I don't just walk...  after the first month I started working out in a gym doing cardio and weight training.  Back then I could do maybe 5 minutes on a lifecycle.. now I can do 2 hours on a treadmill or eliptical.

OHHHHHHHHh the biggest side effect.... darn.. almost forgot to mention.
I'm down about 115 lbs since October 1, 2007.

Now.. problems.. constipation here and there.. easily rectified with flax seed oil or magnesium supplements.
ellesix
on 9/10/08 6:55 am
But what can you eat though? I call myself on a low carb high protein diet and I am starving! I am trying to shrink my liver for surgery!
JerseyGirl1969
on 9/9/08 10:03 am - Milford, NJ
Not to echo Future Legend, but

between Atkins and exercise,

my bp went down 110/70
my glucose went from 122 to normal
my cholesterol remained perfect
I lost 60lbs
my resting heart rate lowered to 54
my energy skyrocketed

I'm a broken record.  Whenever I meet someone...like a few days ago...who complains that they can't lose and yo yo constantly, I give them my prescription.  I share my exercise regime, how to figure out calories, exercise and recipe links...and encourage them to try it before giving up on weight loss.

Neecee O.
on 9/9/08 12:22 pm - CA
The most effective?  WW. WhY: the accountability (blogging, weigh ins, etc), the way you learn to eat what everybody else eats in the right portions, the way you eat lots of veggies, fruits especially.

Most amazing for the short term?  Atkins - no hunger, at least n the short term. No accounting if you stick to fresh unadorned foods. It's the grain cravings that killed me in the end. I tend to be a pasta-bread-fruit-cheese person by basic nature, so it took real conviction to even try it.

Where i am for now & probably forever:  South Beach (and in my book, the Zone is close enough to get a cigar when compared). I just feel better eating more animal protein and can live with small portions of quality whole grains.

Atkins way simply scares me for the amount of fat, esp sat fat with my familial history. I also feel better (as in more satsified with less food) with a more moderate amount of fat - 35-50%, just cannot go to the 60-80% that Atkins pushes.

Eating more often, and restricting cals to a more moderate level (1400-1600) works for me.

"The only way to keep your health is to eat what you don't want, drink what you don't like, and do what you'd rather not."   ~Mark Twain

HollyRachel
on 9/9/08 4:17 pm

"the way you learn to eat what everybody else eats in the right portions"

Funny you said that, today is my second day back on it and I'm having a hard time fitting all my foods in.  I  always have this problem at first when I rejoin WW, and always get yelled at by the leader.  I've been told multiple times to start fresh the next day because I don't use up most of my points.

I had to redo my dinner a bit and I still didn't get in all my points.  I still have three points left and I ate six times.  I feel like a vending machine today.lol  My stomach hurts so I'm not pushing it now.  It's amazing how you get use to eating a certain way.  Unfortunately my way must not be the correct way! :)  I eat more Core (or like too), but I want to "relearn" all about portion control so that is why I'm on flex atm.  With fruit and veggies not being many or no points I can end up eating all day!  That's the downfall of flex in my books.   I'm learning my eating habits are either extremely good, or I live in a restaurant all day.  Need to find that "happy medium"!

 

Sheryl R.
on 9/10/08 6:37 am - Buckley, WA
I love your avatar!  My sentiments exactly!

Sheryl

                                                 Only "obese" now!

Most Active
Recent Topics
Hello
sele444 · 0 replies · 443 views
Here's how to lose 5 Pounds a Day!
Siam · 0 replies · 574 views
Hi all
Traleen · 1 replies · 764 views
Plant Based
ebonymc2 · 1 replies · 996 views
×