Question here...Bear with me, Iam sure its been asked alot...

Gael T.
on 3/22/08 9:01 am - CA
Ok, so if thisdrives ya nuts... Doofussorry...lol   Ummm, if anyone can answer this, or send me a link to an older post would be great  The basic differences between Atkins and South Beach....From what I've gathered on the web, it looks like SB allows more fruit, and doesn't like the "full" fat stuff like sour creme as Atkins does?  Iam sure there are more differences, just would like your opinions before I get a book. Thanks, oh and have a great Easter Bunny Face  Easter Church 


Newly crowned:  Official VSG Lady in Waiting  King  










Donnamarie
on 3/22/08 9:36 am, edited 3/22/08 9:37 am - NY

Hi Gael, I wouldn't spend a whole lot on the book.  you can get most of your information online.  The premise of South Beach is low carb/low fat.  Frankly it's nothing like Atkins although some people like to put the two together.  I think it's the low carb thing that they have in common.  Atkins is actually high fat, so totally different then South Beach.

I could never consume butter and high fat sour cream or all that cheese.  My stomach would totally rebel.

good luck in whatever you choose.

"Accountability first to yourself, then nobody else matters"

        
Gael T.
on 3/22/08 11:21 am - CA
Thanks Donnamarie, I subscribed to an online low carb site, and they cover alot of the plans, give shopping lists, recipes ect...I'm kinda in between the 2 plans cause I can't hack the lo fat cheeses, but do like the cottage cheese and s.creme(lo fat).  Iam excited about not having to stress over weighing foods, and don't "volume" eat, so portion size isn't an issue (snacking is my issue).  Also, in a pinch I want to be able to have the frozen SB meals.....I figure a month of mixing it up, see what happens, will adjust it if need be.  Iam not in a race.  I can always come here and whine eh? Laughing 2 


Newly crowned:  Official VSG Lady in Waiting  King  










Future Legend
on 3/22/08 11:10 am - SC
I believe Atkins is based more on ketogenics... it takes fat to burn fat.  Also, I think it's lower carb than South Beach. 
Gael T.
on 3/22/08 11:27 am - CA
Thanks Future, I think you are correct I noticed certain breads were allowed, and a lil fruit.  If it doesn't go well, in a month I'll have to tweek it


Newly crowned:  Official VSG Lady in Waiting  King  










Most Active
Recent Topics
Hello
sele444 · 0 replies · 443 views
Here's how to lose 5 Pounds a Day!
Siam · 0 replies · 574 views
Hi all
Traleen · 1 replies · 764 views
Plant Based
ebonymc2 · 1 replies · 997 views
×