JUST CURIOUS. WHY SO MANY VSGs AND SO FEW RNYs DONE IN MEXICO?

greatdanemommyfore
ver

on 7/17/13 10:28 pm - Winthrop, MA

I have noticed that there are more VSGs then RNYs here on the Mexico  board., Why so few RNYs here? Isn't RNY popular in Mexico? Just curious.

Jennifer L.
on 7/18/13 6:23 am - Dayton, OH
VSG on 07/10/13 with

RNY is a slightly more complicated surgery. I dont know people who had RNY in Mexico but I know people who had the DS in Mexico and things turned out fine. However, both DS and RNY are complicated surgeries. The VSG is far less likely to have complications, and it is the cheaper option generally. That is just my understanding behind it all. RNY and DS both have high risks, a bit of a longer recovery time, ect. 

HW: 275 SW: 265 CW: 200 GW: 135 Month 1: -25 Month 5: -65lbs total
On the fence about self-pay options and if Mexico is the right choice (or scared of that option)? Let my experience (first time ever in Mexico) be your guide. Don't let fear hold you back!

Instagram

"You make me new, you are making me new" Gungor

christine500
on 7/18/13 11:59 am

On the other forum I actually see a lot of people having those type of surgeries in Mexico.

greatdanemommyfore
ver

on 7/20/13 12:00 am - Winthrop, MA
Thanks so much everyone for replying to my question. Robyn, I am having the RNY revision done in Mexico. I don't know whether to just have the RNY revised and a belt put around the pouch or to go with the duodenal switch. And if I do the ds, I understand that only a few drs. in the world do this. I may be wrong. But that is just what I have seen on the internet. One thing is for sure, I don't want to regain my weight again after 8 years. So whatever will keep the pounds off, that is what I will go for. I cannot afford to regain my weight back.
LVeronica
on 7/20/13 8:59 pm

I did note that your BMI is only 31, yet you are planning on having a revision.  What is your thinking behind this plan.  Just curious.

LVeronica
on 7/19/13 1:13 pm, edited 7/20/13 8:53 pm

Our local (USA) bariatric surgeon has only started doing vertical sleeve gastrectomies.  The surgeons in Mexico seem to have been doing them for several years.  I chose vertical sleeve gastrectomy because I knew weight loss would be easier for me if I didn't feel hungry, and I did not feel I needed the malabsorptive component of surgery.  It also was attractive because the risk of nutritional deficiencies and functional problems are less. The surgical complication rate for VSG is also less than Roux-en-Y. Since I was having surgery in Mexico and not close to home, a lower complication risk was a very attractive factor. The fact that vertical sleeve gastrectomy cost about $1500  less was a bonus, but not a deciding factor.

tdbull
on 7/19/13 10:03 pm - WA
RNY on 08/13/13
I'm having my band removed and RNY in TJ on Aug 13. I suffer from severe acid reflux and little to no restriction with my band. My surgeon recommend RNY over the sleeve due to my reflux

Lapband surgery in 2009 -  Revision to RNY August 13, 2013 with gallbladder removal.

HW - (260)   SW - (197)   GW - (135), updated on 1-2-14 to 125lbs  HT 5'5"  Goal reached 3/2/14-revised goal to 120 on 3/9/14   reached 4/6/14             

    

Most Active
Recent Topics
My journey
AbiM · 0 replies · 503 views
Mexico said NO
waarce · 0 replies · 707 views
Dr. Alvarez, Endobariatrics
msmith434343 · 0 replies · 1281 views
Surgery at Pompeii Surgical?
JCler97080 · 4 replies · 1921 views
×