New to these forums
![](http://images.obesityhelp.com/_shared/images/smiley/msn/smile.gif)
Hey John, 1. My doc told me that open is safer because the doc can actually see what they are doing "first hand." If I had it to do over, then I would go lap. The open way hurts like a ******! 2. Experience is what makes a doctor a good one, not whether they are listed on some website. I'm sure you did your homework. 3. The drive will be a pain, get it. Don't worry, you will be doped up anyway. 4. Don't even think about doing any food prep pre-op because your outlook on food, and your tastes will change drastically. 5. I would change the procedure to lap DS (just being honest). Those guys tend to lose more, and can still eat more. I'm still happy with my decision to have RNY though. 6. Sounds like your doc is setting a realistic goal, one that she knows you will accomplish. Based on the success of many of us "guys", you will blow right past 294, and propbably drop to at least 225. The surgery does a lot of the work for us, but you still have to watch what you eat, and exercise regularly, to be successful. Glad you found us! Ronnie
![](http://images.obesityhelp.com/_shared/images/smiley/msn/smile.gif)
First of all Welcome John,
1. My surgeon does lap and only changes to open if he has to. I had lap and could have been back to work in a week, but took two because I had already planned it.
2. Nope. As long as you have checked him/her out; number of procedures done and complication rate and so on.
3. I had a 40 minute ride on the way home. I felt pretty good, but it did hurt a little when my wife would hit a big bump. The pain was from one of the incision sites where it was stapled.
4. I wouldn't do anything prior to surgery. Now I fix my lunch to take with me either the night before or when I fix breakfast. For a long time I would just go to Wendy's for a small chili and a side salad.
5. Can't really think of anything
6. My highest weight prior to surgery was 375 to 380 range. 360 my first visit with the surgeon. I was 324 my last weight before surgery, I had to do a 6 month pre-cert diet for ins. Thursday was 50 weeks and I weighed 173 this morning. I went from a size 54 jeans to 34. I would think that 200 is a real possibility. Follow your Nut's diet plan and get moving. Walking is the main form of exercise that I have done. I started about two or three hours after surgery and haven't stopped since. Good Luck pan head
![](http://www.franklinmint.com/images/B11A027l.jpg)
John,
Welcome to the Men’s Board!
I’ll take at stab at these…..
1. Other than cost, is there any reason to choose open vs lap RNY?
Go with what ever your doc has the most experience or success with.
Lap is great, particularly with recovery time, but if your doc has done 1000 Open and only 20 Laproscopically? I would ask for the “Old School.”
2. My surgeon was not listed here. Should I be concerned? (Lily Chang, MD FACS)
Nope. Just means they didn’t put out the bucks to be “Sold” by THIS Site. Paul in
![](http://images.obesityhelp.com/_shared/images/smiley/msn/laugh.gif)
Capricious; Impulsive, Semi-Predictable