What do men want?
Eric, I’m so glad to see you checking in here. Like many of the guys who visit this page, you’ve received invitations form me. I’m a bit of "The Men’s Forum Pimp," for a various reasons…. When I first started reading AMOS in ’02, and even when becoming a participant in ’03 There were so few men on the site, typically lost out on the estrogen sea that is this site. Like most men, I wondered- "Where are the guys?" Which led me to check into Male percentages for Bariatric procedures. In ’03, the standard figure given by Docs - (or at least the Baptist Memorial Healthcare organization) was-- "Men make up 12% of the people seeking WLS." By ’05 the standard reply given by the folks at Baptist Memorial Healthcare was "19%." I would risk to bet, that with more and more successful post-op men being out in the local communities and sharing their "stories" with others, the numbers by the end of ’07 will be 25% or higher. So much of the experience that is shared on the Main board is specifically "for the gals." When "The Men’s Board" was established in June ’05, at the same time as the "Grads Board," Both were in need of enough ‘traffic’ to keep them viable and valuable Forums. In the first months, both Boards were logging about 50+ post/replies a day some more, some less. Both were on their way to being very valuable. It would make sense that the High traffic of the Main Board would naturally transition to the Grads Board and keep it an active valuable forum. However, presently, the "Grads Forum" logs approx. 25 post/replies per day (or less) whereas the Men’s Forum typically has 150+ per day. I think this is the result of the shared sub-interests grouped under one forum, which speaks directly to your question of "Shared Interests/Goals." For example, the Grads forum, by it’s very nature, does not traffic in information about selecting a procedure, finding a surgeon, dealing with transitioning to solid foods, etc… The "Topics" are somewhat limited to "Finding a Plastic Surgeon," and "Bounce-back Re-gain." There is also a general perception/tendency on the OH site (recently) of the "De-Valuing" of the older-further-out-Post-Ops in favor of the more "Chatty" MySpace-ish posts and replies about family, spouse, girl friends, etc… There has been (in the last 6 months) a literal Migration of Grads off to other sites Because they feel snubbed and de-valued by the community in general and "Member Services" specifically. On the contrary, The Men’s Forum, where one would expect to see less growth, has continued expanding it’s participation because it can share experience on a near limitless range of topics. It is difficult to actually have any subject be considered "Off-Topic" here, when adding the phrase- "For Men." "Advancing diet?-for Men?" "Movies of Interest?-for Men?" " Hobbies? –for Men?" etc… As to whether or not the "Obesity Community" values these guys? It’s also of little to no impact. This Forum is (for the most part) left alone to pass information and experience peer to peer without The Sorority-esque personality clashes that plague the Main-Board and that Member services spends So much of their time having to ‘De-Tangle’ with nothing but the TOS and personal judgement calls. Under the umbrella of "Just us Guys," older-further out-post-ops can pass on their experiences and newer Pre-ops can revel in small daily victories without the Fem-cultural implications and social "one-ups-manship" that is found in the typical Female Group Dynamic. The lack of "Cattiness" can not be overstated in explaining the successes of this forum. I presented a "seminar" at the Lexington OH Convention on just this issue- http://obesityhelp.com/forums/men/a,messageboard/action,repl ies/board_id,5479/cat_id,5079/topic_id,3189221/ As well as a study/survey comparing the differences in how men and women interact/experience the Process of WLS. That survey of Bariatric Surgeons/Clinics yielded some valuable info about Men. As a rule, we do indeed reach goal weights much quicker than our female counterparts. We tend to have higher complication rates- But specifically due to the fact that we tend to wait far longer to address the health issues of Obesity prior to seeking medical solution. The survey also uncovered one remarkable difference between men and women specifically about support groups. Men, as a rule, tend to "drop-out" of any structured support group system at a near 10 to 1 rate over the Gals. Even though Men show far greater resulting benefits to overall health from bariatric procedures, we often stop participating in "after-care" due to the fact that most support groups are "femi-centric" and follow the "Breast-Cancer-Survivor" paradigms already in place at most hospital systems. It is ironic that Men, the very group that tends to benefit Most from the Bariatric Community’s ability to pass peer to peer experience, are the one’s that are least addressed by the typical support group system. I have tried to utilize this forum and the speaking presentations I give at various Bariatric Seminars and Support groups to off set that fact little bit by little bit. The idea of ‘sub-groups’ dedicated to specific interests and Goals, can be quite beneficial to the growth of the main board, particularly if those can remain "clumped" so as to not be thousands of individual goals but groups of shared goals. But I also think such ‘sub-grouping’ would diffuse the inherent strength of this Forum. Perhaps Scott’s suggestion of a "Men’s FAQ’s" Page, maybe in the "Content" section of this Forum, would be very valuable. Presently the "Content" link here provides only- "Men’s Forum" on February 16, 2007 read more… (followed by) Welcome to the ObesityHelp Men's Forum. This seems in great contrast to the "Exercise & Fitness Forum" which has extreme "Content." http://obesityhelp.com/forums/fitness/ But typically that Forum has about 10 to 12 post/replies per day. (and that, even with dedicated Daily posters) The "Exercise/Fitness Forum" arrived whole and planned at it’s inception, while this Forum began under the "old-system" and has developed prior to "Design." As a result, it seems to offer the sort of "More than You Ever Wanted to Know" content that may overwhelm and make for a more "passive-reader" interface than this forum. I can’t say enough how happy I am to see you dropping in here and posting/replying to get a sense of how the "users" are using the various features while working to improve those features. As AMOS continues it’s evolution under your direction, I hope the "Men-WLS nexus" will be given the attention that this growing and valuable aspect of the WLS Community warrants. Some other aspects of "The Guys" that might be useful ‘back-burner’ info….When considering "Want Men Want?" An area/thought that I think Paul touched on in a way--- The vast majority of the men here are still professionals with less time for the online life than their ‘house-wife’ counterparts on the Main Boards seem to have. We tend to have our hands on and make the household decisions about allocating more disposable income. Whereas literally hundreds of main board gals may be interested in "free-Samples" from one of the many "Bari-Specific" product suppliers that advertise here, the men tend to be more likely to just purchase a product based on a trusted recommendation then decide whether or not they like it. The women may have the market cornered on ‘fussy-shopping’ but guys will tend to impulse buy and then rationalize it to their wife later. :-) Likewise, (and this is an observation shared by some of the guys at the Lexington Convention) Men tend to pass on info or recommendation for products that "worked for them" in an un-alloyed directness that is stronger than seen among the ladies. For example- At a meeting, guys are likely to say- "Here, try this stuff, it’s great and cheap." And then hand an Ostrim stick to several of the guys in the group. No thought to the cost of the products, just ‘sharing.’ The gals are more likely to mention a few items that they tried in the past and talk in terms of "free-samples." Sort of that same- ["I’ll get the check.." at the restaurant] macho activity that is in contrast to "Ladies at Lunch" splitting the bill 12 ways and even sub-splitting a shared desert onto multiple bills at the chagrin of the poor waiter. Yes? I’d go so far as to say that trusted testimonials have more impact on the "Men as customer" than on the women and that Men will more readily drop more cash than the women if they perceive value in a particular product. Perhaps the Marketing folk could utilize that angle? A far fetched example would be "The Online Support Meeting- Sponsored by GNC." Sort of the "GNC-Support Chat!" Much the same as Nascar or the long tradition in sports of "Busch" Stadium and "Wrigley" Field. Just a thought. I think men are less "offended" by straight-forward commercialism and don’t need to think of OH as a "Non-profit Family" in order to find it valuable. I think most of us are comfortable with a "Business is Business" approach. One other area that Scott touched on- Banned Members? Obviously if people are disruptive to the day to day exchange of peer-to-peer experience, then they must be managed in some manner for "the good of the whole." Yet, in the last few months, many of the further out (3 to 4 year+) post-ops have been "excommunicated" from the OH message Boards. As a member watching from the outside, it seems counter-productive to the ongoing value of OH. There ‘seems’ to be a ‘personal’ agenda driving these bannings rather than an even application of the TOS. It ‘seems’ that Member Services is responding on a personal an emotional level rather than an ‘even-handed’ application of policy. The message boards have at their very core a certain amount of "Personality or Celebrity Driven" attraction. Some posts by frequent posters are sure to receive more views and replies than other threads. When disagreement or tension arises between various "high-profile members" then result, in the past years, was just more activity on the site. People would clam down, continue and agree to disagree. Here of late, some of those disagreements are between high-profile members who work within the organization and those who are just members. The result has been the banning of otherwise valuable contributors to the content of this site. Several "Parallel WLS Support Message Boards" have either sprung up or had remarkable increases in membership as a result of others following banned members away from AMOS to places that are not seen to be "Personality Driven." Scott felt strong enough about such an incidence as to go "Off-Topic" here at the slight chance that "The Big Guy at the Top" could help alleviate just one of these instances. I won’t wade into this topic here, except under the umbrella of "What Men Want," I think we "want" a fairly open forum for the exchange of experiences, free from to much filtering. As a High-Profile contributor to the Men’s Forum, I was asked at the Lexington Conference by some of the OH admin folk if I thought this Forum needed (or would be benefited by) the inclusion of a ‘waiver-page’ as an entrance to this forum. Sort of like the one that the "Sex-B4 & After" Forum utilizes. The discussions here can often be blunt, gruff and direct. That, -and from time to time penises will be discussed!:-) Humor can run to the ‘off-color’ side from time to time. My response was this… The nature of the Men’s Forum is that it self-regulates fairly well. Perhaps it is the "Male-Group-Dynamic," but the typical "drama" and attempts at flaming that can crop up on the main-board, are (99.9% or the time) absent from this forum. I felt, and still do, that such a ‘waiver-page’ would only serve to scare-off those who are more conservative and embolden those who are prone to more outrageous and off-color remarks. One of the attributes of this board that others in this thread may have been referring to by their comments of- "If it Ain’t Broke, then Don’t Fix it," was the aspect of inclusion on the Forum. The very fact that Ministers and Strip Club Owners, Factory Workers and Lawyers, Openly Gay Hairdressers and Surely Bikers, can coexist very harmoniously is a testament to the unique experience that this board/forum has become. Just some guys who have or had very deep navels sharing their experiences. Filtering or "Moderating out" - un-popular, contrary or simply blunt responses because they may seem "Un-Supportive" would be a definite detriment to this forum. I would venture to say that this unique aspect of this forum / message board, would benefit the rest of the OH message board policy as well. The "Don’t Pick at It- It’ll Never Heal" school of thought, that serves this forum, would help with some of the "Inflammation" seen on the Main Board. Men, would naturally find the rest of the forums of OH more useful and valuable if that were always the case. Just my Thoughts….
Thanks for taking me up on my invitation. As to a "General message" that would be generated to all men joining OH? So far, I have tried to serve that function as best as possible.:-) About a year and a half ago I very quickly posted to some guy out on the Main-Board---- ----------------------------------------------------- "I just wanted to drop by an Invitation. It’s great to see other men out here. We make up such a small percentage (12%) Of the people having Weight Loss Surgery, But tend to reach our goal weights quicker and with less Or at least Different hassles than the Gals Due to Male physiology. Drop by the Men’s Message Board And check out what other men like you are going through. It’s a diverse make up of Dads, Singles, Older, younger, etc… Pre-Ops, Post-Ops new and some Old (at Goal) Post-Ops. Lap-Banders, RNY’ers DS, etc… Great bunch of guys with the mutual understanding That WLS for Men can be a totally different Journey. Stop by to add your questions, advice, opinions, and info at- http://www.obesityhelp.com/forums/men/ It’s Great to know we’re not so alone, And that there are others pulling for you. Hope to see you ‘Round the Boards! Best Wishes- Dx" ------------------------------------------------------------ To date, I’d estimate I’ve Copy/pasted that same message to some 400+ Men. (I never got around to re-writing it.) Thank-you for dropping in here, and for the AMOS site in general. The content provided by these folks over the years has helped so many make the transition from Life-Threatening Obesity to Healthy Futures. I hope OH and this Forum in particular, continues to improve, grow and aid in the lives of more people. Do drop back by as often as possible? I think Men are a rapidly increasing component to the WLS-Community and one that has been ‘under-served’ in the past. Well, I’ve nearly reached my usual Long-azzed reply length… And I’m off to finish some drawings…. Thanks So Much! Best Wishes- Dx
Capricious; Impulsive, Semi-Predictable