Does anyone have anything good to say about Lap-Band?

annie0039
on 5/21/14 4:11 am

Sure! if your looking for a Short Term WLS the Band is IT, But Do expect to Need another surgery down the road.

If your looking for Statistics and comparisons look to the Medical literature then decide because a 50% rate seems pretty high to me.  Google the complications then decide

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3038361/

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12152154

Complications from the manufacturers that SOLD it off just recently ;)

http://www.allergan.com/assets/pdf/lapband_dfu.pdf

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

tbone88
on 5/21/14 4:38 am - MO

LMAO So your statistics from your medical report are from a study done 20 years ago on 90 patients? Yep those are some good #'s. The band didnt even get FDA approval in the US until 2001. Your study wasnt even conducted on patients in the US.

Stephanie M.
on 5/21/14 8:57 am

It's one of the studies still being used today to sell the Lapband.  More recent studies show much higher rates of re operation/removal.  

Here's Allergan's physician guide.  

 

http://www.allergan.com/assets/pdf/lapband_dfu.pdf

 

  6-7-13 band removed. No revision. Facebook  Failed Lapbands and Realize Bands group and WLS-Support for Regain and Revision Group

              

kaytiebugs
on 5/21/14 4:48 am - Flowery Branch, GA

I'm 5 years post op lapband. I don't HATE my band, but I don't love it either. I haven't had any serious complications but I haven't been able to find the "sweet spot" with my fills since after my first post-op pregnancy. So basically it's either too tight or too loose. It's either I can eat EVERYTHING or I can eat only mushy foods. And that's after many attempts to find that perfect sweet spot. Right now it's pretty much empty and therefore serving no real purpose.

I don't "regret" having WLS but honestly I do wish I'd never had it. My band is basically useless right now and has been for a long time. When I first got my surgery, I was excited and told people about it. I advocated WLS. But 5 years later honestly I think that unless you have SERIOUS mobility issues, people don't need WLS. People just need to get their act together, find a diet that works for them, stop giving up after a couple of rough months, eat healthy, exercise etc..

I am currently at my all-time lowest. I gained a chunk of weight when I was pregnant with my second post-op baby. I was 10 lbs away from my SURGERY WEIGHT when he was 3 months old! I didn't use my "tool" to lose this weight. I stopped making excuses and did what needed to be done. I started REALLY trying in September. I've lost about 45 lbs since then. I workout 6 days a week, eat healthy 85% of the time, count my calories/macros on my fitness pal, watch my carbs, avoid grains etc.. Yes, that's 45 sad little pounds in 8 months of consistently eating right and exercising religiously. I have PCOS but I'm not letting my slow progress hold me back or discourage me. Slow progress is better than NO progress.

I thought surgery would magically "fix me" both mentally and physically. This far out from surgery and I've only recently been serious about "fixing" my relationship with food. I'm proof you can have food addiction and still lose weight, but you WILL gain it back.

Most surgeons are so quick to perform WLS but one HUGE factor that's barely touched on post-op is getting your MIND right with food. It takes a LOT more than a little pre-op class on what you have to eat for the rest of your life to get your crap together. I though paying thousands of dollars and being cut open would "fix me"... well that's a big fat LOL.

I'm ranting at this point. In short, don't have surgery. Just focus on figuring out how you became morbidly obese (bad relationship with food in most cases ... I had PCOS and Hypothyroidism but I will never say that I became morbidly obese due to these things... those things were the loaded gun but my food choices pulled the trigger). Focus on finding something that works for you LONG TERM. When things get hard and discouraging, keep going anyway.

Karen D.
on 5/22/14 2:34 am - NY
Revision on 11/24/15
On May 21, 2014 at 11:48 AM Pacific Time, kaytiebugs wrote:

I'm 5 years post op lapband. I don't HATE my band, but I don't love it either. I haven't had any serious complications but I haven't been able to find the "sweet spot" with my fills since after my first post-op pregnancy. So basically it's either too tight or too loose. It's either I can eat EVERYTHING or I can eat only mushy foods. And that's after many attempts to find that perfect sweet spot. Right now it's pretty much empty and therefore serving no real purpose.

I don't "regret" having WLS but honestly I do wish I'd never had it. My band is basically useless right now and has been for a long time. When I first got my surgery, I was excited and told people about it. I advocated WLS. But 5 years later honestly I think that unless you have SERIOUS mobility issues, people don't need WLS. People just need to get their act together, find a diet that works for them, stop giving up after a couple of rough months, eat healthy, exercise etc..

I am currently at my all-time lowest. I gained a chunk of weight when I was pregnant with my second post-op baby. I was 10 lbs away from my SURGERY WEIGHT when he was 3 months old! I didn't use my "tool" to lose this weight. I stopped making excuses and did what needed to be done. I started REALLY trying in September. I've lost about 45 lbs since then. I workout 6 days a week, eat healthy 85% of the time, count my calories/macros on my fitness pal, watch my carbs, avoid grains etc.. Yes, that's 45 sad little pounds in 8 months of consistently eating right and exercising religiously. I have PCOS but I'm not letting my slow progress hold me back or discourage me. Slow progress is better than NO progress.

I thought surgery would magically "fix me" both mentally and physically. This far out from surgery and I've only recently been serious about "fixing" my relationship with food. I'm proof you can have food addiction and still lose weight, but you WILL gain it back.

Most surgeons are so quick to perform WLS but one HUGE factor that's barely touched on post-op is getting your MIND right with food. It takes a LOT more than a little pre-op class on what you have to eat for the rest of your life to get your crap together. I though paying thousands of dollars and being cut open would "fix me"... well that's a big fat LOL.

I'm ranting at this point. In short, don't have surgery. Just focus on figuring out how you became morbidly obese (bad relationship with food in most cases ... I had PCOS and Hypothyroidism but I will never say that I became morbidly obese due to these things... those things were the loaded gun but my food choices pulled the trigger). Focus on finding something that works for you LONG TERM. When things get hard and discouraging, keep going anyway.

Well said!

vlp1968
on 5/22/14 8:31 pm
On May 21, 2014 at 11:48 AM Pacific Time, kaytiebugs wrote:

I'm 5 years post op lapband. I don't HATE my band, but I don't love it either. I haven't had any serious complications but I haven't been able to find the "sweet spot" with my fills since after my first post-op pregnancy. So basically it's either too tight or too loose. It's either I can eat EVERYTHING or I can eat only mushy foods. And that's after many attempts to find that perfect sweet spot. Right now it's pretty much empty and therefore serving no real purpose.

I don't "regret" having WLS but honestly I do wish I'd never had it. My band is basically useless right now and has been for a long time. When I first got my surgery, I was excited and told people about it. I advocated WLS. But 5 years later honestly I think that unless you have SERIOUS mobility issues, people don't need WLS. People just need to get their act together, find a diet that works for them, stop giving up after a couple of rough months, eat healthy, exercise etc..

I am currently at my all-time lowest. I gained a chunk of weight when I was pregnant with my second post-op baby. I was 10 lbs away from my SURGERY WEIGHT when he was 3 months old! I didn't use my "tool" to lose this weight. I stopped making excuses and did what needed to be done. I started REALLY trying in September. I've lost about 45 lbs since then. I workout 6 days a week, eat healthy 85% of the time, count my calories/macros on my fitness pal, watch my carbs, avoid grains etc.. Yes, that's 45 sad little pounds in 8 months of consistently eating right and exercising religiously. I have PCOS but I'm not letting my slow progress hold me back or discourage me. Slow progress is better than NO progress.

I thought surgery would magically "fix me" both mentally and physically. This far out from surgery and I've only recently been serious about "fixing" my relationship with food. I'm proof you can have food addiction and still lose weight, but you WILL gain it back.

Most surgeons are so quick to perform WLS but one HUGE factor that's barely touched on post-op is getting your MIND right with food. It takes a LOT more than a little pre-op class on what you have to eat for the rest of your life to get your crap together. I though paying thousands of dollars and being cut open would "fix me"... well that's a big fat LOL.

I'm ranting at this point. In short, don't have surgery. Just focus on figuring out how you became morbidly obese (bad relationship with food in most cases ... I had PCOS and Hypothyroidism but I will never say that I became morbidly obese due to these things... those things were the loaded gun but my food choices pulled the trigger). Focus on finding something that works for you LONG TERM. When things get hard and discouraging, keep going anyway.

Except for the pregnancies, my story if very similar.  Never got to a sweet spot for more that a couple weeks here and there during my journey.  Lost 100 pounds, but didn't feel like the band was the tool I hoped it would be.  I also choose to keep my band loose.  I want to be able to eat breakfast, have some healthy carbs like brown rice and whole wheat pasta.

Lori W.
on 6/6/14 12:50 pm - Pittsburgh, PA
RNY on 05/12/14
Lori W.
on 6/6/14 12:52 pm - Pittsburgh, PA
RNY on 05/12/14
On May 21, 2014 at 11:48 AM Pacific Time, kaytiebugs wrote:

I'm 5 years post op lapband. I don't HATE my band, but I don't love it either. I haven't had any serious complications but I haven't been able to find the "sweet spot" with my fills since after my first post-op pregnancy. So basically it's either too tight or too loose. It's either I can eat EVERYTHING or I can eat only mushy foods. And that's after many attempts to find that perfect sweet spot. Right now it's pretty much empty and therefore serving no real purpose.

I don't "regret" having WLS but honestly I do wish I'd never had it. My band is basically useless right now and has been for a long time. When I first got my surgery, I was excited and told people about it. I advocated WLS. But 5 years later honestly I think that unless you have SERIOUS mobility issues, people don't need WLS. People just need to get their act together, find a diet that works for them, stop giving up after a couple of rough months, eat healthy, exercise etc..

I am currently at my all-time lowest. I gained a chunk of weight when I was pregnant with my second post-op baby. I was 10 lbs away from my SURGERY WEIGHT when he was 3 months old! I didn't use my "tool" to lose this weight. I stopped making excuses and did what needed to be done. I started REALLY trying in September. I've lost about 45 lbs since then. I workout 6 days a week, eat healthy 85% of the time, count my calories/macros on my fitness pal, watch my carbs, avoid grains etc.. Yes, that's 45 sad little pounds in 8 months of consistently eating right and exercising religiously. I have PCOS but I'm not letting my slow progress hold me back or discourage me. Slow progress is better than NO progress.

I thought surgery would magically "fix me" both mentally and physically. This far out from surgery and I've only recently been serious about "fixing" my relationship with food. I'm proof you can have food addiction and still lose weight, but you WILL gain it back.

Most surgeons are so quick to perform WLS but one HUGE factor that's barely touched on post-op is getting your MIND right with food. It takes a LOT more than a little pre-op class on what you have to eat for the rest of your life to get your crap together. I though paying thousands of dollars and being cut open would "fix me"... well that's a big fat LOL.

I'm ranting at this point. In short, don't have surgery. Just focus on figuring out how you became morbidly obese (bad relationship with food in most cases ... I had PCOS and Hypothyroidism but I will never say that I became morbidly obese due to these things... those things were the loaded gun but my food choices pulled the trigger). Focus on finding something that works for you LONG TERM. When things get hard and discouraging, keep going anyway.

I can't believe no one has responded negatively to your post. This is one of the most condescending posts that I've ever seen here. An obese-to-thin person now preaching to obese people that it just takes will-power to get thin.  The same thing we all hear from a society of fat-bashers. Whether you admit it or not, your WLS has helped with your weight loss. You still have a band that restricts, whether it's full or empty.

Mell
on 5/21/14 5:03 am

Had mine sin 2006 with one replacement, not perfect but have maintained a 110lb loss. Still love living the banded life!

I do agree it is not for everyone, and most of us with good things to say get beat up a bit here but usually from those who have had really nightmare cases and are ligament worried about others.

Mell
Start weight: 320
At surgery:  300
Current:      185
Goal:           175

SeriouslyDoubtful
on 5/23/14 4:34 am

Mell, I just wanted to tell you that I really appreciated your response.  I am glad you are doing good with your band...  

Most people think if we say something negative that we are "haters" and that is just not the point.  I just want people to know what the worst is that 'can' happen and if they are willing to take the risk from there, then I wish them well...   I know when I got my band, I was 'misled' by my surgeon.  He told me the ONLY time the band slips, etc., is when you do not follow the rules and I wanted people to know that even when you follow the rules, something bad may happen...

 

Most Active
×