Interesting Anectdotal Information re Lapband complications vs Sleeve Complications

Stephanie M.
on 3/16/13 2:28 am

As I was perusing another site, it occurred to me that they post the number of topics in each forum.  That's when my curious mind went "hmmm?"...

The complications forum for each site (each is dedicated to one particular WLS) show significant differences in the number of topics:

Sleeve:

 

Gastric Sleeve Surgery (VSG) Complications Support Group

Come here to give and receive support with others who are experiencing Gastric Sleeve Surgery (VSG) complications (heart burn, leaks etc.).


  1. Struggling Sleevers
  • 219 topics
  • 4,507 replies
 

Lapband Forum:

 

 

Lap Band Complications

Receive and provide support for Lap Band Complications and Lap Band problems such as Lap Band slippage, Lap Band erosion, Lap Band pain, infection, leaks, pb, gas etc.

  1. Struggling Lap-Bandsters
  1. Life After Lap-Band Removal
  • 3,292 topics
  • 30,139 replies
 

It's not scientific, but it is a real indication of the reality of current trends in complications....

 

 

  6-7-13 band removed. No revision. Facebook  Failed Lapbands and Realize Bands group and WLS-Support for Regain and Revision Group

              

Stephanie M.
on 3/16/13 2:35 am

...and this from the same site success stories

 

 


Congratulations! You've made a life-changing decision and are now benefiting from this new, positive lifestyle. Please share your Gastric Sleeve Surgery and story with our Vertical Sleeve Gastrectomy Surgery (VSG) community. It's easy, it's fun, and you may make the difference in someone else's life.

  • 3,698 topics
  • 46,532 replies
 

Bands:

 

 

Lap Band Success Stories

Congratulations! You've made a life-changing decision and are now benefiting from this new, positive lifestyle. Please share your story with our community. It's easy, it's fun, and you may make the difference in someone else's life.

  • 796 topics
  • 10,952 replies
 

I think the numbers tell the story...

 

  6-7-13 band removed. No revision. Facebook  Failed Lapbands and Realize Bands group and WLS-Support for Regain and Revision Group

              

Nic M
on 3/16/13 4:34 am

And yet, there are so many ostriches with their heads buried in the sand. It's a shame.

Are we really so desperate to lose weight that we'll risk our complete health to do it? Rhetorical question... I know that the answer is "yes."  (Because I was once that desperate myself.)  Now I know that being fat isn't the worst thing in the world... chronic pain from damage caused by the band is much worse.

 

 

 Avoid kemmerling, Green Bay, WI

 

annie0039
on 3/16/13 8:44 am

THANKS SM I LOVE SHARING FACTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!angry

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

LilSleeved
on 3/16/13 4:25 pm

I have said this before and I'll say it again.  The LapBand existence just makes me sad AND a little angry.

I know what it's like to have both procedures and the difference is night and day.  Each person gets WLS for the same reason, to be a healthy weight.  Most work very hard, follow all of the instructions and do as they are asked - with the Sleeve, they lose, they meet their goal and they are happy, with the LapBand, they struggle, take the long road to their goal, IF they ever reach there and then end up having a complication and another surgical procedure!  (yes! NOT everyone will have a complication, but the odds are against a LapBander)

I believe if  you want to be a healthy weight, the Lapband is not the answer.  If you want to work hard and see results, you need to find a different solution.  With all the evidence that is out there, I am very surprised anyone gets the Band anymore.

    
    
Lost 271lbs with my LapBand in 22 months!  My Band malfunctioned and I gained almost 42lbs and then revised to the Sleeve 9/24/12!  I lost another 140 lbs with my Sleeve!  Loved the LapBand and Lovin' The Sleeve!

Stephanie M.
on 3/17/13 5:20 am

As I sit here, burping over 3 tiny pills after a miserable day yesterday, I'm pretty pissed too.  I made an appointment with my PA (have to see her before the doctor) to explore removal/revision.  I've been having epigastric pain and port pain for two days.  Not a good sign.

 

  6-7-13 band removed. No revision. Facebook  Failed Lapbands and Realize Bands group and WLS-Support for Regain and Revision Group

              

annie0039
on 3/18/13 9:47 am

 I'm sooooooo sorry that your going through the pain and discomfort SMblush

it is beyond ridiculous that we have to Jump through so many hoops to get results and our bands removed when we experience problems.cool

I sure hope things will be resolved for you SOON!!!

 

 

 

 

 

 

Stephanie M.
on 3/18/13 11:41 am
I have an appointment tomorrow at 11am.

 

  6-7-13 band removed. No revision. Facebook  Failed Lapbands and Realize Bands group and WLS-Support for Regain and Revision Group

              

Iam_with_the_Band
on 3/18/13 2:31 pm

It is time for you to get some relief.  You've done your due diligence with the LapBand .

You desire to live a painfree life!

12/09 and 6/11, 9 skin removal procedures with Dr. Sauceda in Monterrey Mexico
Revised to the Sleeve after losing 271 lbs with the LapBand. 

Stephanie M.
on 3/19/13 1:16 am

My appointment is at 11 am, will update this afternoon.

 

  6-7-13 band removed. No revision. Facebook  Failed Lapbands and Realize Bands group and WLS-Support for Regain and Revision Group

              

Most Active
×