Is Soy milk better for you?

carrie1835
on 7/16/11 5:54 am
Is Soy milk better for you or is just a preference thing? I have tried it in my protein ice cream and it taste yummy, asl improves the taste of my shakes but it's higher in fat than my milk.

Thanks!
Carrie
    
MARIA F.
on 7/16/11 8:16 am - Athens, GA

I used to do 2% milk and I now do either the almond or soy milk. It's fewer calories, and I like that it stays fresh longer! I hate buying milk and throwing half of it away.

 

   FormerlyFluffy.com

 

tripmom02
on 7/16/11 9:02 am - NJ
 It is not better for you, and recent studies show that in can increase the risk of several cancers. 

Courtney - Lap band to VSG revision
      

    
(deactivated member)
on 7/17/11 12:00 pm - Califreakinfornia , CA
Do you have any links to these studies because my daughter has recently switched to soy from cow.
shamr0ck
on 7/17/11 8:09 am
Adjustable Gastric Band on 12/20/10
It's especially bad for you if you have any thyroid issues.
Highest weight - 224   Surgery weight - 201   Current weight - 155
Goal - (surgeon) 155; (personal) 138-bodyfat 20%

    

    
Bette B.
on 7/17/11 8:15 am
 from livestrong.com:

The Health of Soy Milk Vs. Cow Milk

Overview
One of these drinks has no calcium, the other is full of cholesterol. When it comes to your health, it's easy to see that soy milk and cow milk both have their upsides and their flaws. To choose the best one for you, take a look at their nutrients and their health benefits.

Soy Milk Nutrients

Soy beans are crushed to make soy milk, a beverage that combines protein, water and oil. A serving size of one cup of soy milk has 5 g of total fat, 4 g of carbohydrates and 80 calories. It contains 30 mg of sodium and 7 g of protein. At 6 percent of daily value per serving, soy milk is rich in vitamin B-6, and has 10 percent magnesium, phosphorous and riboflavin, and 25 percent of thiamin.s

Soy Milk Health Benefits

With soy beans containing more protein than any other legume, soy milk is high in protein. Protein helps the growth and maintenance of your body tissues, including your organs and muscles. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said in 2009 that as part of a diet low in saturated fat and cholesterol, 25 g of soy protein daily can decrease cholesterol, thereby reducing the chances of heart disease. Soy milk isn't dairy, so even lactose intolerant people can drink it. And unlike cow milk, soy milk is low in saturated fat, contains almost no cholesterol and has 10 percent of daily value of dietary fiber -- a plus for your digestive system -- and 8 percent of iron -- an essential mineral needed for oxygen to travel throughout your body. It's also rich in omega-3 fatty acids, which, according to the American Heart Association, may slow plaque growth in arteries and lower triglycerides or fats in the blood.

Cow Milk Nutrients

Whole milk contains 10 g of carbohydrates, and 5 g of saturated fat which is about 25 percent of your daily value based on a 2,000 calorie diet. It has 10 percent of the daily value for cholesterol or 35 mg, 125 mg of sodium and 8 g of protein. There is no dietary fiber in a cup of whole milk.

Cow Milk Health Benefits

Unlike soy milk, cow's milk contains 30 percent of the daily value of calcium, a supporter of teeth and bone health. It also has 25 percent of the vitamin D, a vitamin that maintains the health of your skin. It possesses even more protein and phosphorous -- another plus for bones and teeth -- than soy milk does. If you're watching your cholesterol, you can always switch to skim milk or low fat milk, as they have less cholesterol but the same benefits of calcium. Harvard School of Public Health stated that both dairy and calcium may help to reduce colon cancer and osteoporosis. The National Milk Producers Federation announced that the 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommends that adults and children above the age of 9 drink three servings of low fat milk daily.



    

Banded 10 years & maintaining my weight loss!! Any questions, message me.

Bette B.
on 7/17/11 8:16 am
 
Soy Milk vs. Cow's Milk by Robert Cohen

 

 

Let’s compare 100-gram portions (3.5 ounces) of soymilk vs. cow’s milk:

Cow’s milk has 61 calories. Soymilk has 33 calories.

Cow’s milk contains 3.34 grams of fat. Soymilk contains 1.91 grams of fat.

Cow’s milk has 14 milligrams of cholesterol and no dietary fiber. Soymilk contains 1.3 grams of fiber and has zero cholesterol.

Cow’s milk contains a full range of amino acids. Soymilk also contains a full range of amino acids.

Both contain plenty of protein. Cow’s milk actually has one- half gram more protein than the 100-gram portion of soymilk.

Soymilk contains greater amounts of certain amino acids including arginine, alanine, aspartic acid, and glycine.

Arginine slows the growth of cancers by strengthening the immune system. Alanine aids in the metabolism of sugars. Aspartic acid increases stamina and plays a vital role in metabolism, acting as an anti-oxidant. Glycine is necessary for brain and nervous system functioning and muscle/energy metabolism.

When milk is pasteurized, Vitamins A, C, and D are destroyed. The same can be said for those vitamins when soymilk is manufactured. Soymilk does contain more than four times the amount of thiamin (Vitamin B-1) and nearly twice the amount of niacin (Vitamin B-3) as does cow's milk.

Soymilk also contains more magnesium, copper, and manganese than does cow’s milk. In order to absorb calcium, one needs magnesium. Copper also aids in bone formation. One early sign of osteoporosis is a deficiency in copper. Soymilk contains twelve times the amount of copper as does cow’s milk. Soymilk also contains 42 times the amount of manganese as does cow’s milk. Manganese is also needed for bone formation. People with anemia rely upon manganese for iron storage. Trace amounts of manganese are essential for neural transmissions, protein metabolism, and many other body functions.

    

Banded 10 years & maintaining my weight loss!! Any questions, message me.

carrie1835
on 7/17/11 8:31 am
Thanks Bette!
Carrie
    
Catapult
on 7/17/11 12:10 pm - Australia
I just wanted to add that you can get soy milk fortified with calcium.

HOWEVER: my husband (a medical scientist) looked at the literature and found that soy milk has phytic acid in it which prevents the absorption of some minerals and vitamins. So he won't allow soy milk in the house anymore, even though we both enjoy it.

We have tried rice milk (almond milk is twice the price of rice milk or cow milk).

Cat.
        
Most Active
×