Anyone 3+ years out? (Xpost to VSG)
I'll respond on both boards since I have had both surgeries and I'm over 4 years post op:
When did you have your surgery? 12/6/06
Was it your first wls, or revision? First
How much weight did you want to lose? 100#
How much did you lose after the first year? 132#
Did you reach goal? Goal and weight I did not want to lose.
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off? Yes, but it was intentional.
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it? Severe malnutrition that took about six months to recover after having the band removed. Permanent damage to my teeth from all the vomiting, permanent esophageal damage all due to the band.
Quite frankly, the sleeve is far more effective, better weight loss, safer long term, and cheaper in the end.
When did you have your surgery? 12/6/06
Was it your first wls, or revision? First
How much weight did you want to lose? 100#
How much did you lose after the first year? 132#
Did you reach goal? Goal and weight I did not want to lose.
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off? Yes, but it was intentional.
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it? Severe malnutrition that took about six months to recover after having the band removed. Permanent damage to my teeth from all the vomiting, permanent esophageal damage all due to the band.
Quite frankly, the sleeve is far more effective, better weight loss, safer long term, and cheaper in the end.
Previously Midwesterngirl
The band got me to goal, the sleeve will keep me there.
See my blog for newbies: http://wasabubblebutt.blogspot.com/
The band got me to goal, the sleeve will keep me there.
See my blog for newbies: http://wasabubblebutt.blogspot.com/
Mell
on 1/28/11 4:22 am
on 1/28/11 4:22 am
HI,
I had surgery 10/2007
First WLS
I wanted to loose 100lbs
After the first year I lost 100
I did reach my goal and then some, I lost a total of 115lbs
I had some regain after a slip and unclip but lost it after they re clipped me
I still want to loose 20 more lbs (after baby of course)
No nutritional deficiencies
Good luck!
I had surgery 10/2007
First WLS
I wanted to loose 100lbs
After the first year I lost 100
I did reach my goal and then some, I lost a total of 115lbs
I had some regain after a slip and unclip but lost it after they re clipped me
I still want to loose 20 more lbs (after baby of course)
No nutritional deficiencies
Good luck!
Mell
Start weight: 320
At surgery: 300
Current: 185
Goal: 175
Mell
on 1/30/11 11:40 pm
on 1/30/11 11:40 pm
It is rare, the band when placed is cliped into place. Well mine became unclipped, I think the doctor when he went in to fix my slip did not clip it correctly or at all. I changed doctors after that!
Mell
Start weight: 320
At surgery: 300
Current: 185
Goal: 175
When did you have your surgery?
01|17|08 (3 years)
Was it your first wls, or revision?
First WLS
How much weight did you want to lose?
214 lbs
How much did you lose after the first year?
100 lbs within 16 months
Did you reach goal?
not yet, had a complication (port leak) that I just got fixed last week
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
yes, I regained 60 lbs during 2010 because of port leak and non-compliance on my part. I have taken approx 8 back off (just re-starting my journey with a repaired band)
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it?
no... but I did find it difficult and frustrating to eat some healthy foods like meat, lettuce, broccoli, etc
01|17|08 (3 years)
Was it your first wls, or revision?
First WLS
How much weight did you want to lose?
214 lbs
How much did you lose after the first year?
100 lbs within 16 months
Did you reach goal?
not yet, had a complication (port leak) that I just got fixed last week
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
yes, I regained 60 lbs during 2010 because of port leak and non-compliance on my part. I have taken approx 8 back off (just re-starting my journey with a repaired band)
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it?
no... but I did find it difficult and frustrating to eat some healthy foods like meat, lettuce, broccoli, etc
When did you have your surgery?
11/08
Was it your first wls, or revision?
First and only
How much weight did you want to lose?
100
How much did you lose after the first year?
40
Did you reach goal? 27 away
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
no regain at all
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it?
No
11/08
Was it your first wls, or revision?
First and only
How much weight did you want to lose?
100
How much did you lose after the first year?
40
Did you reach goal? 27 away
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
no regain at all
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it?
No
Hi,
I can answer for both sleeve and band:
When did you have your surgery?
June 2003 for band and march 2008 for sleeve
Was it your first wls, or revision?
Revision from band to sleeve
How much weight did you want to lose?
160 lbs
How much did you lose after the first year?
120 pounds with band and 75 with the sleeve and goal.
Did you reach goal?
Yes with band, then regained back to 242 and then sleeve
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
Yes with band due to slip and regained 62 pounds. I gained 10 lbs back with sleeve but have been maintaining within 10 lbs of my lowest weight with sleeve for the last 15 months.
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it? None with band but I have iron deficiency anemia and low d with sleeve. Then I found out its not the sleeve but a gastrobleed caused by crohns
The sleeve rocks!! No regrets but I did have regrets with the band after 5 years of slippage, dilation and achalasia of the esophagus.
Babs
I can answer for both sleeve and band:
When did you have your surgery?
June 2003 for band and march 2008 for sleeve
Was it your first wls, or revision?
Revision from band to sleeve
How much weight did you want to lose?
160 lbs
How much did you lose after the first year?
120 pounds with band and 75 with the sleeve and goal.
Did you reach goal?
Yes with band, then regained back to 242 and then sleeve
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
Yes with band due to slip and regained 62 pounds. I gained 10 lbs back with sleeve but have been maintaining within 10 lbs of my lowest weight with sleeve for the last 15 months.
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it? None with band but I have iron deficiency anemia and low d with sleeve. Then I found out its not the sleeve but a gastrobleed caused by crohns
The sleeve rocks!! No regrets but I did have regrets with the band after 5 years of slippage, dilation and achalasia of the esophagus.
Babs
When did you have your surgery?
May 2006
Was it your first wls, or revision?
1st
How much weight did you want to lose?
80lbs
How much did you lose after the first year?
about 85lbs (can't remember exactly)
Did you reach goal?
went 45lbs BELOW goal
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
once - my own fault! 27lbs. Lost it all ( bar 2lbs) again in 8 weeks
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it?
No. Eat a totally normal diet.
May 2006
Was it your first wls, or revision?
1st
How much weight did you want to lose?
80lbs
How much did you lose after the first year?
about 85lbs (can't remember exactly)
Did you reach goal?
went 45lbs BELOW goal
Have you regained weight? If so, how much, and did you take it back off?
once - my own fault! 27lbs. Lost it all ( bar 2lbs) again in 8 weeks
Have you had any nutritional deficiencies, and how did you handle it?
No. Eat a totally normal diet.
Highest 290, Banded - 248 Lowest 139 (too thin!). Comfort zone 155-165.
Happily banded since May 2006. Regain of 28lbs 2013-14. ALL GONE!
But some has returned! Up to 175, argh! Off we go again,