Coming out to the closet!
Andrea
Andrea
I'm really so sorry to hear this - but this is exactly why a yearly routine fluoro is so important. MANY problems are found before symptoms occur, and often while they still can be fixed fairly easily.
However, it's pretty unusual to have such a serious problem with NO symptoms at all. I don't know of ANY cases in more than 7 years of my banding experience where there was a "major slip" but absolutely no symptoms. I'd urge you to get a second opinion, since you're not having a bit of trouble. It may be entirely possible , with a highly-skilled surgeon, to simply re-position ore entirely replace the band in the same surgery.
Don't give up quite yet - you have not really looked at all possible options. You may even want email Dr. Curry here about your situation. (Find his thread at the top of the page here) Scan or email him a copy of your BA swallow also, and see what he thinks.
There are also surely other band docs near you to consult in person. It's your right and - really - obligation to yourself to do this before you accept band-removal surgery in a situation that is not urgent.
Good luck - sure hope things end up OK for you.
Sandy r
band educator
DISCLAIMER: Any suggestions or comments are not intended as medical advice, but only as general information. Please always contact your own surgeon or his staff for any specific problems or concerns you are having. Although I have many years as a medical professional and band educator, I offer suggestions here only as an experienced Bandster.