Failure?

I was a member on this site several years ago, but have gotten out of the habit.  Actually, a lot of things related to getting my Lap-Band in August of 2007 are no longer "habits".  Admittedly, I haven't been the best WLS patient.  I started at 284, and lost 60 pounds in the first 8 months, and not another ounce since.  That loss was purely through restriction and diet -- no real exercise initially.  My question is this:  Since I have maintained the weight loss for 4 years, is it still considered a failed WLS because I have only lost 26% of my excess weight??

I'm curious for personal reasons (considering revision in the near future), but I'm also writing a paper for a class and would like to give some real-world examples and arguments.

Thanks for any input!
Sonja

Oops - my percentage posted above is wrong... I never claimed to be a math wiz!  I have actually lost 41% of my excess weight.  My goal weight is 140 and I still have 84 pounds to go.

Sonja

Hi Sonja,

I think you are still in the race.  Maybe get some help from a support group, a nutritionist and maybe a counselor who specialises in food issues (addictions, disorders, bariatrics). 

Do you have a Curves near you?  They have a super super circuit and weight management program that is fast, fun and safe.  If not, find a place you feel comfortable and start getting some exercise if you aren't doing anything.  Find something you enjoy.

The band is only a tool.  As you know, any weight loss surgery requires a life style change.  It doesn't cure our mind. 

Hang in there!

Thanks for your support!!  I actually started the Beachbody ChaLEAN Challenge with a coach and 4 others last week.  I got all my workouts in during the week and am eating within my calorie range.  Down 4 pounds!!  I know its just a matter of getting back into the mindset again and I can do this!

I would not call you a failure personally. You did lose a good chunk of weight. As for the band I
dont believe it worked the way it should have. They are revising all of the studies because they
have more results to apply. They have re-estimated the success rate of the band from 60% to
only about 20%. It is not you or anything you did or did not do.

I would talk with your doctor and see what he says as far as if it is medically considered a
failure. Also, call your insurance company and see if they would consider it a failure (if you
are really considering a revision). That way you can have all your questions answered.

Terry

Thank you for your response, Terry.