Magnesium Citrate (TMI)

Liz J.
on 11/13/18 8:02 am
DS on 11/29/16

So, I was taking the wrong type of Magnesium until last week when I switched and all of a sudden my bathroom habits have increased drastically. This has been the only change in daily food/supplements, well and I haven't taken any Mirlax the last few days... Anyone else have this problem or is this why most other DSer's I've talked to don't need daily Mirlax?

Liz

HW: 398.8 SW:356 GW: 175 CW:147

PeteA
on 11/13/18 8:26 am - Parma, OH
DS on 04/15/13

Did you switch from Oxide to Citrate? I was on oxide the first year to help my stools but except for the first couple of weeks I never had a problem with constipation and I put that down to the pain meds.

I never saw a dramatic change as I switched to / added mag citrate to my vitamins.

Pete

HW 552 CW 198 SW 464 4/15/13 - Lap DS by Dr. Philip Schauer - Cleveland Clinic.

Liz J.
on 11/13/18 8:32 am
DS on 11/29/16

I was on Glycinate and that was only for a week before I found out I was using the wrong one. I wasn't taking it before...

HW: 398.8 SW:356 GW: 175 CW:147

chevtow41
on 11/13/18 12:34 pm
DS on 11/11/14

Glycinate is correct one, absorbed better than citrate.

Liz J.
on 11/13/18 12:37 pm
DS on 11/29/16

Vitalady say Citrate.

HW: 398.8 SW:356 GW: 175 CW:147

PeteA
on 11/15/18 1:04 pm - Parma, OH
DS on 04/15/13

Two thoughts of my own.

1) The Vitalady list is older so there might not have been enough info at the time
to say glycinate over citrate.

2) Unless you are deficient the bioavailability difference isn't very high so in practical terms
it may not matter which one you use. I tend to use them interchangeably based on what is available
when I am filling my monthly organizers.

Pete

HW 552 CW 198 SW 464 4/15/13 - Lap DS by Dr. Philip Schauer - Cleveland Clinic.

Liz J.
on 11/14/18 2:47 pm
DS on 11/29/16

Well, second day with no Mirlax and everything is MOVING!! Woot!

HW: 398.8 SW:356 GW: 175 CW:147

H.A.L.A B.
on 11/15/18 12:12 pm

The citrate can help with bowel but some people better absorb other forms.

The improved bowel function - means most likely that you are absorbing less, and the extra magnesium ends up in the colon and increase volume by attracting- getting more water into that area.

I try to take a combination, some to absorb to get better stronger bones and less muscles spasms, and some to help with BM.

Hala. RNY 5/14/2008; Happy At Goal =HAG

"I can eat or do anything I want to - as long as I am willing to deal with the consequences"

"Failure is not falling down, It is not getting up once you fell... So pick yourself up, dust yourself off, and start all over again...."

Most Active
Recent Topics
×