Recent Posts
Definitely do your own research & determine what is best for you. You should also take a hard look at your dieting past. Were you able to lose by just restricting only, or was every pound a struggle no matter what you did. Each surgery has its own pros & cons. The sleeve is a restrictive only procedure, while the rny & ds are restrictive & malabsorption procedures.
Try going to a seminar where you can learn all of them & maybe meet wl patients. I'm guessing at your appointment you will talk about your medical history, current medical condition. Dieting history, insurance, what you expect from the procedure and what he expects for you as a result of the procedure. Usually I'd guess you'll get & do a lot of paperwork.
![](https://images.obesityhelp.com/uploads/profile/1315856/tickers/1lasttime21440f36067e5824965f860e0761058f.png?_=8935028638)
No one surgery is better than the other, what works for one may not work for another. T-Rebel
Please do your own research. Some surgeons have a preference based upon what surgery they like performing and not based on what is best for each individual patient.
Also, with your BMI I think you should also research the DS.
Laura in Texas
53 years old; 5'7" tall; HW: 339 (BMI=53); GW: 140 CW: 170 (BMI=27)
RNY: 09-17-08 Dr. Garth Davis
brachioplasty: 12-18-09 Dr. Wainwright; lbl/bl: 06-28-11 Dr. LoMonaco
"May your choices reflect your hopes and not your fears."
I'm having some bounce back action going on, but I know it's water weight. I had to wait a bit to make sure. I've upped my bike riding a lot for the last week & my body went into oh **** I have to hold onto every molecule of water mode. So it shot right up to 200lbs at 1 point where I went into freak out mode, my tom didn't help things any, but I took a breath & stayed the course, where it went down to 199, then 197. So its finally starting to calm down some. That 192 was starting to feel like a teaser, but I'm guessing when my body stops freaking out & gets used to my new normal, I'll be back on point again. So my stats so far:
High weight 366
Last week 192
This week 197
Next goal 180's (surgeons goal)
![](https://images.obesityhelp.com/uploads/profile/1315856/tickers/1lasttime21440f36067e5824965f860e0761058f.png?_=9278091880)
No one surgery is better than the other, what works for one may not work for another. T-Rebel
Hang in there, everyone!! This is my 8th holiday season since my RNY. For me, it has gotten easier to get through as time goes by. Usually I gain 5-7 pounds and then lose them in the spring but right now I am maintaining.
Highest Weight: 339
Goal Weight: 140
Today: 140
Yippee!!
Laura in Texas
53 years old; 5'7" tall; HW: 339 (BMI=53); GW: 140 CW: 170 (BMI=27)
RNY: 09-17-08 Dr. Garth Davis
brachioplasty: 12-18-09 Dr. Wainwright; lbl/bl: 06-28-11 Dr. LoMonaco
"May your choices reflect your hopes and not your fears."
Welcome! I went to Mexico so my experience is totally different than you will have so I'm not sure what to tell you for the appointment.
For the type of surgery, I recommend reading everything you can here. You will see the good, bad, and ugly. It helped me tremendously. This is a great place to learn and ask questions. Good luck!
![](https://images.obesityhelp.com/uploads/profile/1329827/tickers/keishaleigh3062b58c6fb3f33dd9270ea20794cda9.png?_=8969588180)
38 y.o. 5'7" HW 347 SW 332 M1 -22 M2 -18 M3 -19 M4 -9 M5 -18 M6 -11 M7 -13 M8-9 M9 -7 M10 -8 M11 -5 M12 -1 M13 -9 M14 -0
I had an amazing week on the scale. I got up yesterday and it read 199.6! Well I had a little bounce back today. So I'm not officially going to count it until I see it multiple days in a row..but I know it is coming soon. It's going to be a great Christmas present to myself.
High Weight 347
Last week 203
This week 200
Next goal 190 - officially only overweight
![](https://images.obesityhelp.com/uploads/profile/1329827/tickers/keishaleigh3062b58c6fb3f33dd9270ea20794cda9.png?_=2758724765)
38 y.o. 5'7" HW 347 SW 332 M1 -22 M2 -18 M3 -19 M4 -9 M5 -18 M6 -11 M7 -13 M8-9 M9 -7 M10 -8 M11 -5 M12 -1 M13 -9 M14 -0
on 12/15/15 12:41 am
I had the duodenal switch (aka DS) and know it was the smartest thing I've ever done for myself. I had reservations about taking daily vitamins, which would be required also if you have RNY (gastric bypass) but there may be more or different ones.
According to studies the DS is hands down the most effective surgery for losing the weight, and keeping it off. It's also the most effective at resolving co-morbidities, especially type 2 diabetes, cholesterol and metabolic issues. It's the most successful no matter what your BMI is, but there is data showing it's especially good for folks over 50bmi.
You are young, and thinking about whether you will be OK taking supplements for the rest of your life with the DS is important (although don't let anyone tell you that that would not also be the case with RNY). I now take fewer pills in vitamins per day than I used to take to treat my mounting co-morbidities, as those are all long gone. You may not have many yet as you are younger, but they will come, and they trash your body when they do.
Don't get this surgery if aren't sure you can be responsible with the supplementation. If you can, it's life changing. I eat more normally now than I did before my DS. I used to have such disordered eating from fretting about getting a speck of fat in my food, and made my metabolism even more efficient than my fat genetics already had. I was not going to lose, and maintain that loss, on my own. I tried for years thinking I could do it. I had good will power, and decent diet habits, but eventually realized I needed surgical intervention.
My only regret, in total honesty, is not doing it sooner.
As far as traveling, I self paid for my DS outside the US (rather than get RNY paid for right by home by my insurance) and was on planes for 30 hours post op - that's THIRTY HOURS!! That sucked, but it's doable.
The liquid diet is also the pits, but one thing that helped me, was knowing that it was not only temporary, but after I was healed I could eat better and more satisfying foods than I had in decades. Instead of those disgusting rice cakes and similar diet crap, I'd be able to eat higher protein, and higher fat, which makes most food more satisfying. I had bacon wrapped prawns and avacado salad for dinner tonight, which is typical. Not a lot, because even at 8 years post op I can eat a smallish sized meal, but I eat YUMMY food that I actually love, and am actually satisfied after. No longer feeling like I need "just one more bite" because it's so good.
You should ask the surgeons office what they allow on their liquid diet, as I was allowed all the variations of soup, and some surgeons have no liquid diet requirements at all. Just remember as you are chugging down another cup of broth, that it's only for now, and after a few months, you can have prime rib, lobster dipped in butter, etc.
ose
Hey guys!! I'm new to OH and I'm just starting my weight loss journey!!! I just scheduled my first initial visit with my surgeon which will be on the 29th.. And I just wanted to know what should I expect in the first visit? I know of we'll talk about the type of surgery I will want... I'm actually torn between getting the sleeve and the rny.. I'm not sure of my weight yet, I haven't weigh myself.. But I'm guessing I'm close to 400 and I'm only 5'2.. So i was gonna leave that up to the doctor.. But what else should I expect?
Thanks for any comments
Awesome. Stay focused!!
Laura in Texas
53 years old; 5'7" tall; HW: 339 (BMI=53); GW: 140 CW: 170 (BMI=27)
RNY: 09-17-08 Dr. Garth Davis
brachioplasty: 12-18-09 Dr. Wainwright; lbl/bl: 06-28-11 Dr. LoMonaco
"May your choices reflect your hopes and not your fears."