Switching from Diet Soda to Water?

lucalaw28
on 10/19/13 8:29 am

I've used diet soda as a way to not feel deprived (use to drink reg soda all the time).  But I've read that it can slow your weight loss cause it can screw up your metabolism/sugars, etc.  So I want to switch to jus****er and wanted to get some feedback on other's experiences and how switching the water affected you, both physically and mentally.

 

Thanks :)

            
jenorama
on 10/19/13 11:34 am - CA
RNY on 10/07/13

I wasn't a big soda drinker to start with and I quit drinking soda way before my procedure. I am not a big fan of plain water, so I use the liquid favors that have come out by Dasani, Crystal Light, Mio and even Kool-Ade. I stay away from the caffeinated flavors (energy, usually) and it's been pretty okay. Give some of them a try!

Good luck!

Jen

Imakitekat
on 10/19/13 11:51 am - ID
VSG on 09/23/13

I had caffeine headaches afterwards but once I got on water I was good and felt so much better!  As far as regular or diet you ant have either after surgery, my doctor said nothing carbonated, with alcohol for at least a year.  I lost 10 pounds after I got off regular soda!  Once you do it it's not that hard!

            
lucalaw28
on 10/19/13 1:25 pm

I'm not too worried about any withdrawl, I never drink caffeine on my days off from work and it doesn't give me a headache or anything.  I just keep reading how good people feel after switching to water and how their complexion is better and a lot of them start dropping more weight (possible due to an increase in metabolism from the water consumption); so I'm kind of excited, because I've lost a good amount of weight but I still have a ways to go and if it can make me feel and look better I'm all for it :)

            
Nikkal
on 10/20/13 5:10 pm
VSG on 07/18/13
The switch made absolutely no difference for me. My health was not changed, nor were my energy or stamina. My complexion is the same as always. I'm no more or less hydrated.

I stopped because I wouldn't be able to have caffeine or carbonation after surgery, so I tapered off.

I don't miss it, really, in spite of having had at least one diet coke per day on average (I don't drink coffee and I was a tea purist, so if I wanted a quick drink with caffeine, it was diet coke).

I do usually add Mio or something similar to my water, but at nowhere near recommended strength.
Nikke2003
on 10/20/13 9:51 pm - PA
VSG on 05/13/13

I had to slowly wean myself off of regular Diet Pepsi to caffeine free over time. The caffeine was really screwing with me and my surgeon's office tells people not have it after surgery (although of course this varies by surgeon). Then, over some more time... I switched from CF Diet Pepsi to water.

Drinking a large amount of straigh****er is difficult for me. I drink Propel Zero and find myself EASILY taking in 100 oz per day. I don't even miss soda at this point, but it took awhile. I haven't had it in about 7 or 8 months and I'm not looking to go back!

For more info on my journey & goals, visit my blog at http://flirtybythirty.wordpress.com

  

Lisa1023
on 10/24/13 12:30 am
VSG on 03/05/13

i drink very diluted crystal light.  With the amount of water/fluid they want us to drink every day,  I just concentrate on that and find I have no time for anything else (soda) ... well, I wont give up my coffee !

HW  383     SW  371    CW   234     

Laura in Texas
on 10/24/13 2:29 am

Studies have shown that drinking diet soda can lead to weight gain. The sweetness can cause you to crave more sweets, I think is the reasoning. Personally I have been around a lot of post-ops during the last 6 years and have attended many bariatric gatherings and get-togethers. The people who have never gotten to goal or who have had serious regain all seem to drink diet soda. Coincidence? Maybe, but I choose not to risk it.

Laura in Texas

53 years old; 5'7" tall; HW: 339 (BMI=53); GW: 140 CW: 170 (BMI=27)

RNY: 09-17-08 Dr. Garth Davis

brachioplasty: 12-18-09 Dr. Wainwright; lbl/bl: 06-28-11 Dr. LoMonaco

"May your choices reflect your hopes and not your fears."

Most Active
×