Commitment Contracts

Laura Loses Lots
on 5/21/14 2:31 pm - AL
VSG on 12/03/14

    
Sparklingbeauty53
on 5/21/14 10:29 pm

RosyKate73 you are right!  I deserved that comment lol!

 


  I am grateful for my RNY!Sparkling Marcia

 

 

Amy, Daredevil
Extraordinaire

on 5/21/14 10:00 am - Los Angeles, CA
DS on 08/06/13
On May 21, 2014 at 3:55 PM Pacific Time, Sparklingbeauty53 wrote:

Hate the idea.  Totally.  I believe in positive thinking and positive outcomes.  I see it might work for others but not me.  I thrive on praise! To each his own I believe.

Yes, positive outcomes and positive thinking are awesome, BUT "years of economic and behavioral research show that people who put stakes - either their money or their reputation - on the table are far more likely to actually achieve a goal they set for themselves."

Yay for science!

*DS with Dr. Ara Keshishian on 08/06/13* SW: 231 CW: 131 GW: 119 * Check out My YouTube Channel: AmysDSJourney *

   

(deactivated member)
on 5/21/14 10:25 am

One thing may work for one person.It doesn't mean it is not positive.

jubjub
on 5/21/14 11:23 am - Palm Desert, CA
VSG on 06/25/12

We would expect the Stickk approach to work better than a positive approach, in general.  One reason this works, according to research I've read, is that most people perceive the pain of a "loss" about 4x more than an equivalent "gain."  I believe the creators of Stickk are professors in behavioral economics, who built the site around this idea.

The fact that the money is going to a group you abhor is extra motivation.

Heaviest: 313/VSG Pre: 295/Surgery: 260/Maintenance target:190 - Recent: 195 (08/15/19)

1st 2015&2016 12-Hour Time Trial UMCA 50-59 Age Group
1st 2017 Race Across the West 4-Person 50-59 Age Group
4th 2019 Race Across America 8 Person Team

(deactivated member)
on 5/21/14 12:20 pm
VSG on 03/04/14 with

Sorry, but your post title made it sound like you were having someone committed!

Amy, Daredevil
Extraordinaire

on 5/21/14 12:59 pm - Los Angeles, CA
DS on 08/06/13

*DS with Dr. Ara Keshishian on 08/06/13* SW: 231 CW: 131 GW: 119 * Check out My YouTube Channel: AmysDSJourney *

   

jinx0323
on 5/22/14 5:10 am

Didn't weigh****chers do something like this for a while were u had to pay if u gained weight at weigh in.

 

Sounds like a good idea  but rather than a charity I hate I might put it in a jar to give to someone I hate. If I had to hand a jar of money to my brother in law I am pretty sure I would stick to that goal and not have to put a penny innthat jar

×