What would you do?

Because pictures don't lie.  I've seen my one day post op and my one year post op x-rays, the sleeve stretches! 

If pictures don't lie, you must not read fashion magazines ;)

Everyone's sleeve is tighter immediately post-op due to swelling and such. The sleeve generally "matures" from < 1oz to 3-4 oz in the first six months or so as you heal. This is by design and not a sign of mechanical failure.

Go back and re-read my posts - I never said that my surgeon said it was "impossible" to stretch a sleeve.  He was reporting on his experience in the OR, with his patients; he has never actually seen a sleeve that was appreciably stretched.  

Your stomach cannot possibly be larger now than it was BEFORE the sleeve. Not possible.

I didn't say it was larger than before the sleeve! It is larger than the space I had to fill while I was banded!! 

You did say exactly that. Read your quoted text above. You should explain better in the future.

" my stomach is much larger than it was not originally of coarse but much larger than it was post band/pre sleeve. " maybe you should read my quoted text again.  It clearly says "NOT" originally of coarse but later than it was POST BAND/PRE SLEEVE.  That means after my lapband surgery but before my sleeve surgery. The lapband of coarse meaning the amount of stomach left above the band. 

Your stomache size does not change with the band. If you meant just the portion above the band, you should have said so in the first place.

Well, I guess my answer is yes.  I also had a band that didn't work after initial success (by band standards) - and eventually switched to the sleeve.  Luckily for me it has worked well.   Good luck - it's a tough decision

Do you weight or measure your portions? Do you track every bite? Surgery is not magic. We have to do our part. I also get true physical hunger and can eat a TON but make a conscious choice not to most of the time. Even if you get re-sleeved you will have to watch what you eat.