so how do you feel about RNY man on BL?

was just wondering what your opinion was on the Biggest looser having a WLS contestant.

DO you think its fair for the other contestants?


I'm not sure I know what I feel.  I saw the x rays at the beginning of the show and his stomach was still small. I'm wondering if this will be a topic on the upcoming shows?

Hmmm Im not sure either if he starts working that tool the pounds should melt off but what if he missed hie window?? It totally looked like he had already lost about 100 pounds to me with all the rolls of saggy skin. The man totally needs help with losing weight and if this is his last chance to gain some health and quality of life back all the more power to him.

If  this  works for  him then  i am happy for him.

We are given  a tool  to work with  and be compliant.  we do know that he  has not been compliant  lately.

I  hope  he  eats  like he is suppose to  and  exercises.  I guarentee  that  he will  exercise.
And  we know that moving and eating less  workS!!!!  Just my opinion 

I have mixed feelings about that as well, he has the tool but it obviously has not worked for him.  It seems that he does have an advantage over the other contestants but then again he wouldnt be on the show if he really didn't need the help.

I heard that he had issues with his WLS and instead of lossing he gained. I have n't see it so i don't really have that much of an opinion on this.

Oh my goodness.  I watched the show last night in tears.  Not sure why but it may have been because all of the people seemed to need this opportunity so much. 
It seemed to me that the RNY guy wasn't working the WLS plan.  I don't know that his wls will really be of any help to him in this arena.  If is pouch is still that small he must be a grazer who isn't making good choices.