Recent Posts

Maria C.
on 1/13/10 2:13 am - KY
Topic: RE: Dr. David Geller? Lapband or Gastric Bypass? Do "fills" hurt?

Hi, Holly.  I hope I can clear up a few misconceptions you seem to have about DS.

I went to Brazil because my health insurance excluded ALL weight loss surgery for ANY reason.  However, I would have gone to the ends of the earth for my DS, whereas you couldn't pay me to have RNY or lapband, for all the reasons I put in my previous post.

I did not just show up in the ER when I had a complication.  Dr. Husted wasn't seeing patients yet, so I went to an experienced bariatric surgeon, who does not perform DS but is certainly educated about it.  He had been recommended to me by my sister-in-law, who is an endoscopic nurse and had worked with this surgeon before.  He handled my case without hesitation, and my health insurance covered the entire bill.   In most cases, patients with complications either return to their surgeon, or their surgeon coordinates by phone with a doctor the patient chooses close to their home.  DS surgeons are quite accustomed to working with other doctors long-distance.

The rate of complications with DS is no higher with DS than with RNY.  In the old days, DS was performed only on patients who had BMIs over 60, which places them in a much higher risk category no matter what type of surgery they have.  Now that DS is being performed on folks with all BMIs, including "lightweights", the complication rate is about the same. 

DS has been performed for over 20 years in its current form.  However, the sleeve portion has been performed since the 1800's for various stomach ailments such as cancer and ulcers.  And the intestinal portion is performed in other countries exclusive of the sleeve portion solely for the successful treatment of diabetes.  Medicaid and Medicare have covered it for several years.  Why?  Because it works.  It is not considered "experimental." 

The reason most surgeons don't perform DS is simple - money.  It takes several months of proctoring under another surgeon to learn to perform DS because it is a much more complex procedure to learn, and most doctors don't want to put their profitable practices on hold for that.  In addition, a doctor can perform 2 RNY surgeries or 3 lapbands in the time it takes to do one DS, so they earn 2 or 3 times as much money doing those surgeries.  Plus they don't make all the money on the fills and unfills that they do with lapband.

As for follow up care, it's true that if you don't take your supplements, your health will suffer, but that's the case with any weight loss surgery.  Since there is a greater amount of malabsorption with DS than RNY, you'll get into bigger trouble and faster with DS, but if you don't intend to follow up and take care of your health by taking supplements and getting regular labs, you have no business getting any WLS.

I made the commitment to get the DS no matter what it would take, because I knew it would offer me the greatest chance to lose the weight, and keep it off forever.  I have personally seen several women *****gained all their weight with RNY, or just never lost it at all with lapband.  I knew if I had to live on a diet for the rest of my life, which is required with the other WLS, that I shouldn't even bother with surgery because if I could do that, I wouldn't need surgery at all.  DS doesn't require me to count calories or fat grams.  I eat whenever I am hungry, rich and satisfying foods, until I am satisfied, several times a day.  I wi**** could be this way for everyone, including you, Holly.  Best of luck with your choice.



HW 246    SW 243     CW - below goal    GW 139     Height 5'3"
hollynelson
on 1/12/10 2:11 pm - Louisville, KY
Topic: RE: Dr. David Geller? Lapband or Gastric Bypass? Do "fills" hurt?
Maria,

I read your post about your experience with your DS -- that you had a leak that took a month to heal and had to find an American surgeon to take care of it after having surgery in Brazil. WOW, your a brave woman. Did you have a hard time finding a surgeon to take care of you or did you just go to a local ER and expect that someone will take care of you? I know complications do happen, but there just arent that many DS done and everything I read said the complication are higher -- not only higher chance of leaks in the immediate post-op period like you had, but high risks of nutritional problems long-term because of the extreme amount of malabsorption. These are not minor problems. These are complications that can kill you. Did you have to pay your hospital bill since the complications occured from a surgery that isn't covered by your insurance? I think Dr. Hess, who has now retired, is known as the father of the BPD-DS, but he only described the procedure less than 20 years ago. I guess there is a reason that most surgeons aren't performing the BPD-DS and it only makes up a few percent of all weight loss surgeries. I read your email with all the links (a lot where dead links) and I am wondering how you made the commitment to go out of the country to have surgery and to have the BDP-DS done?

Holly
wendybburke
on 1/12/10 1:55 pm
Topic: RE: Can someone please give me some advice....?
I would absolutely contact Dr. Sonnanstine at his new office.
It is a little bit of a drive but I assure you that you won't regret it. We live in NKY and it takes us about an hour to get there.

The new office number is 502-867-3303

The new address is:
1138 Lexintong Road
Suite 230
Georgetown , Ky 40324
newwavetiff
on 1/12/10 4:02 am - Batavia, OH
Topic: RE: Can someone please give me some advice....?

Dr. Sonnanstine did my surgery when he was in Northern Kentucky but has since went to Georgetown.  I'm not sure how that will work for me since I haven't seen him since he was up this way.  But I will check it out and see.

Thanks very much!

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket 
Leanne31
on 1/12/10 3:06 am - Louisville, KY
Topic: RE: Can someone please give me some advice....?
Congratulations on having your first child!  Welcome to the wonderful world of motherhood.  My oldest just got her driver's license today.  You won't believe how quickly the time will go by.

I don't know the answer to your question.  If I were in your situation, I would call my doctor's office or nutritionist and ask for guidance.  If you are breastfeeding, your caloric intake will need to be higher than someone who is not nursing.

800 calories is really low.  Also, you probably will want to wait at least six weeks before you start "dieting" becaue your body needs time to heal from giving birth.  Again, it's probably best to ask your doctor and/or nutritionist since they are the experts!

Good luck to you.
newwavetiff
on 1/12/10 1:31 am - Batavia, OH
Topic: Can someone please give me some advice....?
i am a little over 3 years out after having RNY surgery and lost over 120 pounds.  well, i recently gave birth to my first child and i really need to lose the extra weight!  does anyone know what the calorie limit should be for me daily since it's been over 3 years since surgery?  i remember having 800 calories a day or so, but not sure what it should be now, or if it should be the same amount?  thanks for the help, i really need it!!!!!!!!!
Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket 
_Lisa
on 1/11/10 10:58 pm - Lexington, KY
Topic: RE: Anyone had trouble with Georgetown or Bluegrass Bariatrics?
I had a terrible experience with BBSA-I was going through the pre-op requirements & education classes at the same time that BBSA was splitting from Georgetown & I had to run back & forth between the two offices for appointments!  BBSA's office staff was unprofessional & rude to me everytime I was there!  When I finally completed all the pre-op requirements I got an email from Georgetown saying that I could choose to stay & have my surgery by Dr. Sonnanstine or I could have my paperwork officially moved over to BBSA.  I hadn't met any of the surgeons yet, but I stayed at the Georgetown office because their staff was so wonderful!  And I absolutely do not regret it for a minute!  Dr. Sonnanstine is amazing & the staff is like family to me.  
LisaJoKoch
on 1/11/10 9:24 pm - Salyersville, KY
Topic: RE: support group around Salyersville area????
I am from Salyersville, and we don't have a support group, we do need one though!!! some of us girls gets together sometimes  for lunch or dinner. I am sure next time you all can join us!!!  If you need someone just to talk to, shoot me an e-mail and I will get back with ya,  Lisa
I am also on facebook, as lisagibson
Kenworthlady
on 1/11/10 12:22 pm - KY
Topic: RE: support group around Salyersville area????
I am from West Liberty, I would love to find a support group also. I know about 3 more girls from my area that would like to go to one also.
Maybe we can all get together for lunch sometimes. And talk about our progress. and get help from each other.
kenworthlady            
bbinky
on 1/11/10 8:50 am - Louisville, KY
Topic: RE: How was your eating today?
 Hello everyone,

Protein good, water good w/special K, vitamins good, Workout check, then a protein drink on the way home from the YMCA..

So far so good, but I want to eat a little something... Let's hope I make a good choice.

Hope you all have a good night!!
Becky in Kentucky
      
Most Active
Recent Topics
ARH Hazard and Dr Kabir Mehta
Erica A. · 0 replies · 250 views
Dr. Ravi Alapati
cpinckard63 · 0 replies · 1485 views
Paducah, Ky
devonnec · 0 replies · 5290 views
×