Lapband vs RNY

How does a person decide on which WLS to have OPEN FOR COMMENTS. Thanks DollyC

Well for me I did a lot of research & read everything I could, but it all came down to this, I have knees that have to be replaced & I decided on the Lap RNY because I can get the weight off faster, which means I can get my knees done sooner.

I talked with my personal Dr.  Then I visited with others that had had both.  I think everyone feels what they had is the best way to go.  that is the way it should be, I think.  I was ready for the RYN and thought that was the best.  Mostly because I went to Junction City and they really were strong for the RYN.  I then visited with my dr. and he suggested i look into the band.  I also did a bunch of reading and visited with a dr. at Tall grass.  I think I felt that the band was the best for me as I didn't want to deal with all the issues that go along with the RYN.  I am happy with my band.  I can eat most of the foods I love, yet small portions are so great.  I feel I don't feel I have no choices.  My wt. loss has been good.  I have not lost much in the past few months but now that I got another fill I know it is coming off. 

I would suggest you talk to as many people as you can and to the dr.'s.  Mine gave me good advice and options.  She was great.  Good luck to you in your decision.

I agree.  I've read some books, "A Complete Guide to Obesity Surgery" by Bryan Woodward and "Weight Loss Surgery for Dummies" by Marin Kurian, Barbara Thompson, and Brian Davidson (both of which explain all the various WLS procedures, and "Laparoscopic Adjustable Gastric Banding" by Jessie Ahroni.  I check out the OH forums & ask questions there, & recently I asked why people chose the DS over the RNY and got several excellent responses.   Seach for info on the internet; attend informational seminars...and definitely talk to as many people as you can...make an informed decision & choose the WLS that is right for you.  Good luck to you

Lots and lots of research.  Myself, I had the VSG (Vertical Sleeve Gastrectomy).  It is kind of a cross between the two.  You have the reduction of the stomach but no intestinal rerouting.  I had to go to Edmond, OK to do the surgery and most insurance will not pay for it but it is a safer procedure and is getting great results.  Good luck on whichever you choose.