This is TOO much for me...(Long)

Before/Current 427/235
Ok I am going to just basically give you a little advice based on myself. I can't say it will help but I can say it would have helped me. My mother and I have a horrible relationship to this day because of my teenage years. I am still young enough to remember clearly when I was 12 and 13. I did the same thing to an extent, I decided that my mom wasn't "buying" me enough things and everyone around me had more stuff than me so I would just take from other people and take the things she wouldn't buy me from the store. Bad I know, I hate admitting to it, but if it helps, I'll humiliate myself. This went on until i was 16. The theft was mainly at stores, but I did take a few things from people at school, including money. *words cannot describe how embarrasing this is for me to admit* Looking back I can't believe the things I did, but the point is I finally learned my lesson. It was a tough lesson but after many years of counseling I figured out what caused it.
I always wanted to be close to my mom, to have the kind of relationship that I could go to her with any problem I have and not be judged or yelled at or punished for making a stupid mistake. I wanted her to be my friend too. She wasn't interested. I always used to imagine going and having a girls night out or seeing a movie together or making a date to go to lunch ever so often, JUST me and her, not her boyfriend or husband or anyone, just us. Basically my problem was exactly what Nancy is suggesting. I was acting out because my mom and dad were divorced and neither one showed any interest in being my friend...they only wanted to be a parent, an enforcer. To this day I would love for her to call me and tell me to leave the kids with my husband and come out with her to lunch or shopping or something, but she won't and I've accepted that.
My relationship with my dad has gotten a lot better, he calls me all the time and wants me to come over or wants me to invite him over or BBQ or something. My mom however, not so much. I know if you try your daughter will probably act like its the lamest thing in the world and that she isn't interested, but she is. Keep at it. If shes in trouble you obviously don't want to "reward" her by any means, but maybe rent a movie, sit in her room, pop some popcorn and try to brush the surface and get to know her again. Don't ask anything too intrusive unless she offers it as she might feel you're trying to intrude in her life *BIG no, no* Just keep it simple, maybe questions about homework or school or other intrests you know she has (church, shopping, etc). Don't ask about boys, friends, or bring up what has happened...it will only make her defensive. As time goes on she will start to offer more information as she feels more comfortable and builds trust that if she needs to tell you something important that you won't blow up and ground her.
Sometimes the best punishment is psychological. The more she tries to pull away and act out, remember she is your little girl and don't let her get away and believe she isn't loved. The teenage mind is horrible and causes you to believe things that are not true at all. You are probably a very loving mother and do your best to make sure she does right, but she may feel that you don't care about her and instead only care about "ruining her fun" and "depriving her of what the other kids have". I am not siding with her by any means, what she did is wrong, but chances are, she already knows that.
I'm sorry for the long response, I didn't mean to be preachy if thats how it came off nor am I a know it all. I just wanted to try to help with some of my experience.

Before/Current 427/235
Hi (((HUGS))) to you all for your support and encouragement! I did 2 water aerobics classes today and that helped a lot... The school is not pressing any charges and neither are the student's parents... We don't know how much the phone costs yet... My plan is to have her do some community service with a local church that prepares and serves a meal to the homeless... My sister is looking into her taking a tour of the juvenile detention center... I am going to call the social worker at our police department to see if maybe anything they can offer... Brad and I are signed up for "Parenting the Teen" and "Positive Parenting" Classes will start within the next few weeks... Serenity will have to "earn" the money for the phone... We were thinking about canceling our trip to Kentucky, which is over her B-day, and she is bringing a friend, but we are still going as planned and letting her bring her friend. Her punishment from the last time is staying in effect no compromise... I am also going to make an effort to spend some more quality 1 on 1 time with her in hopes that she will see I have unconditional love for her... I just got in from church I am exhausted... I am going to bed! Thanks again! Blessings Jenn

Before/Current 427/235