STOMAPHYX
I guess the "need" for revision - or extra help beyond the original bariatric surgery to assure sustaining weight loss, T. - is subjective. The root of your question seems to me to be about weight regain...is it inevitable that we will regain any or all of our weight that was lost as a result of surgery? I am 3.5 years post-gastric bypass surgery; I am maintaining my weight loss, I have not yet regained any of the 214 lbs. lost. I do not believe it is inevitable that we are destined to regain the weight. Having said that, however, I absolutely believe that the only way to keep the weight off is a daily and vigilent commitment to behavioral AND psychological change - physical activity, hard and often; making healthy eating choices every day for the rest of my life; and, for me this is every bit as important: living a passionate and full life that embraces the philosophy of knowing what I'm made of and then giving it away...in other words, if I can get out of my "puny" self-centered, self-absorbed thinking and instead make it a priority to connect to people and be of service to my community and my world, I simply won't have time to obssess about food. This is the path I have chosen after living most of my life as a super morbidly obese person. Today, I am living life in a normal sized body, and I will go down kicking and screaming before I give that up. So, it is NOT inevitable that we will regain the weight. It IS, however, a daily struggle and to sustain the weight loss will require hard, hard effort for the rest of our lives. The surgery is only a tool - it is not a magic pill, it is not our happily-ever-after. Maybe not what folks want to hear but this is my truth, my reality. Be well, all. Maureen
I have never seen any studies on the actual breakdown of revisions caused by mechanical failures of the original surgery (such as were fairly common before patients' pouches and remnant stomaches were transected) versus those that are caused by patients' overeating and stretching the pouch. My anecdotal experience is that many of us do have a slight bounce up after hitting our record low weights-- some have trouble stopping the bounce or fall into some bad habits (and I fall into this category) which can be rationalized as long as we stay within some range that we feel is "normal" or "o.k." for us. The difficulty, and why I think many of us look into the possiblity of a revision, is figuring out if we are not backsliding into that old mindset where we tried to content ourselves if we only regained a few pounds after a failed diet. And, of course, there are always those few (and I do think they form an absolute minority) who want to blame any weight gain on a mechanical failure (as opposed to sugar free oreos) and who look to a revision as a cure-all. But, I do think that for those of us who have found more struggles as we progress, and who work hard to maintain their "normal" sized bodies, there is always some intrigue with a revision-- with the possiblity that an option exists were we to stumble that would return us to the mindset and hopefullness that filled those first few months of quick and steady weight loss.