5 year weight history~Insurance~

Ok today I went for my 1st consultation with Dr. Barker in Dallas. I was so impressed with everyone there! I feel very comfortable getting this procedure done and they made me feel like I was a sure bet on going forward with RNY. Dr. Barker even mentioned something about it only taking about a month. This sounded too good to be true. When I spoke with the nice insurance guy he mentioned I would need a paper from my PCP showing my weight from 2002 or before. He really was hoping I would weigh 279 or more in 02..well my highest weight in 02 was 251. In JAN of 03 is 262 and that's the best I can get! I'm 17 lbs away from what he wanted to see. However now I weight much more than that. Does anyone know what this means for me?? Why 279! That seems extra high, my fiance thinks he was looking at the mens chart but I really doubt it. Thanks for your help!

Which insurance do you have?