OT: AMERICAN IDOL
DID YALL SEE WHAT HAPPENED?
I know this is posted (several times) on the main board, but I can't quit talking about it
Who are yall voting for?
Me? It's BAMA BO all the way
~*~*~Beth~*~*~
329.4/266/140
http://www.obesityhelp.com/morbidobesity/profile.phtml?N=H1077226915
I think at this point they are all really good and it is hard to see anyone have to leave.
A lot of people vote strictly on the actual one night that they perform, and if that was the case with most people, then in my opinion Constantine should have been the one with the least votes. His performance was the worst last night. Overall, though, he has not done the worst musically or performance-wise. I had a feeling he would be the one going tonight, but I was still surprised. He definitely performs for the camera, but too much so as far as I'm concerned. He seemed to always ignore the audience and only follow the camera around, not very natural on stage when doing that.
My favorites have changed somewhat as I watch and see how versatile some of the singers are. My top 2 in the beginning were Anwar and Nadia. I do think that Vonzell is the most improved. I was not interested in her in the beginning at all. She didn't connect with the audience and was only average in my opinion, but lately she has really done better. I think last night she did have some tuning problems that really bothered me and I think she should have been in the bottom 3, along with Constantine and Scott.
Scott has actually done okay musically the past few weeks with some minor tuning problems, but usually cannot sing in tune and always sounds the same, but he is my least favorite all-around performer at this point.
My top favorites now are Carry and Bo, 2 very unique performers that are very good at what they do already. Bo is very good with the audience, but needs to play to the camera a bit more if he is going to go all the way.
Carrie needs to connect more with the audience every time. She does most of the time, but not always. She has a great sense of pitch and always sings in tune with a good range. She is also very versatile and doesn't just sing country.
Anthony has done okay, but he always sings similar-type songs and is not very creative or versatile when he performs. He has not been and is not a favorite of mine.
Just my opinion.
Sue Z