How do you respond??

Melissa_C
on 6/5/07 10:13 pm
Ok, alot of you guys are familiar with the complications I am experiencing from my mom since she found out I am having surgery. I put up with daily emails/phone calls from her saying various things about how I am making a mistake and should eat less and just excercise. I was sitting next to Billie at support group monday  night and went into the lobby for a few minutes to call and tell her I had just been approved...her reaction was less than thrilled....couldnt she have just faked it? Anyway, I get to work this morning to the following email....really, how can I respond to this??? ***Warning, its lengthy but interesting****

Comments from your Mother... wouldn't it be a sad day if something went wrong during your surgery or after your surgery, and I didn't share all my thoughts and concerns for you .... with you ... and if you had only known ... it could have made a difference.  Only someone that loves you so would be so worried.

If you do have the surgery, I don't want there to be any doubt of my earnest concerns for this procedure and the long term effects.  

I doubt if anything will change your mind, especially now, that you have been approved for surgery; but, at least read the article below with an open mind (especially the last few paragraphs).

Sent with love,

Moma

 

Gastric bypass surgery should be a last resort, not a choice of convenience

by Mike Adams An article in USA Today talks about Raechel Arnold -- a teenage girl who has undergone gastric bypass surgery and managed to lose a significant amount of weight, dropping from 323 lbs to 165 lbs. The article reads like a brochure for gastric bypass surgery, showing just how successful the procedure has been for this girl. This is all part of a recent wave of publicity for gastric bypass surgery as a treatment for obesity, but there's a problem with this approach to surgical procedures and the related publicity in the national press. Too many people are turning to gastric bypass surgery as a choice of convenience -- because they're simply not interested in doing the other things that can help a person lose weight, such as making new food choices or engaging in regular physical exercise. Interestingly, most people end up making these changes after they've had gastric bypass surgery, except now they're missing part of their digestive tract, and the damage to their bodies simply cannot be reversed.

In this case, Raechel says she tried in vain to lose weight, attempting to drop body fat with the Atkins diet, SlimFast meal replacement supplements, Weigh****chers, and weight-loss prescription drugs prescribed by a doctor. She says, "My body was saying it was hungry all the time." Well, it's not difficult to see why these dietary approaches didn't work -- SlimFast, for one thing, is a product that's made primarily with refined white sugar, and trying to lose weight by drinking large quantities of sugar is absolutely ridiculous.

The real problem that Raechel was having here is rather obvious: she has a brain chemistry imbalance that's causing cravings for carbohydrates. So the real problem for Raechel was initially a brain chemistry balancing issue, not the fact that she had too much stomach and needed to have part of it stapled shut or surgically removed. All she needed to do was balance her brain chemistry.

So how do we balance our brain chemistry using natural methods, without turning to prescription drugs or radical surgical procedures? The answer is rather straightforward. I'm willing to bet this is something that Raechel didn't try: natural sunlight. Exposure to natural sunlight has a powerful effect on brain chemistry, and especially on carbohydrate cravings. It works because lack of sunlight results in an increase of melatonin in the brain, which competes for serotonin, and when a person does not have adequate exposure to natural sunlight, melatonin levels are high and serotonin levels are low, causing extreme carbohydrate cravings. This can be quite simply reversed by getting daily exposure to natural sunlight on your skin without sunscreen, thereby suppressing the melatonin and allowing serotonin levels to naturally climb. In time, carbohydrate cravings will be dramatically reduced.

Carbohydrate cravings can also be further suppressed by choosing your foods carefully. If you avoid all refined carbohydrates, such as bread products, breakfast cereals, soft drinks, and anything made with refined white flour or high fructose corn syrup, you will stabilize your appetite and blood sugar levels. Avoiding the consumption of such food ingredients automatically reduces carbohydrate cravings throughout the day, and this is why the Atkins diet and low-carb dieting in general has been so successful for so many people.

The other thing you can do to suppress carbohydrate cravings is to engage in some sort of regular physical exercise. Even daily walking alters your brain chemistry in a powerful and positive way, reducing carbohydrate cravings and enhancing the production of healthful brain chemicals that automatically lead you to healthier dietary choices. These are just a few of the many things a person can do to balance their carbohydrate cravings and alter their brain chemistry in a healthful way, without turning to prescription drugs or radical surgical procedures such as gastric bypass surgery.

And yet, note that none of these things generate any profits whatsoever for organized medicine. There's no drug here, there's no surgical procedure here, in fact, there's nothing here that even needs a doctor. You can go outside and get sunshine on your own, every day, absolutely free, at no charge. You don't need approval of the FDA, you don't need 20 clinical trials telling you that sunlight is good for you, and you don't need the advice of a doctor to get sunlight and benefit from it. You also don't need medical personnel to help you make healthier food choices. You simply need to educate yourself about nutrition, and the difference between healthy foods and unhealthy food, and by the way, that information is not generally known by physicians because nutrition is not taught in medical schools.

So when people say that they are undergoing gastric bypass surgery after "trying everything", the truth of the matter is they haven't tried everything, and probably they haven't even tried the basic things such as natural sunlight, exercise and food choice. If you try those three things, and actually do them, and still manage to remain extremely obese, only then does it make sense to seek additional help, and even in that case, gastric bypass surgery should be something that's considered only as a last resort. The interesting thing about all this is that even if you have gastric bypass surgery, you will have to control your food choices after the surgery, making sure you don't eat too much sugar, that your portion sizes are very small, and that, for example, you eat your protein first. If you would just make these changes to your lifestyle before having the surgery, you probably wouldn't need the surgery at all. And you can live your life with your entire digestive system intact.

Unfortunately, today gastric bypass surgery is being marketed and promoted to obese patients as a panacea for obesity. It's being offered as a first choice rather than a last resort. It's being sold to people as a way for them to automatically lose weight without having to make changes in their lifestyle.

This brings up another point -- I think there's a great misconception in American society that everything has to be easy, that things have to be convenient and results have to be instant. There's nothing easy about losing weight and making healthy food choices and exercising on a regular basis, at least not at first. Over time, of course, it gets very easy and becomes a natural part of your life, but in the beginning it's not easy at all, and I'm not claiming it is. I know from experience what it's like to be overweight, to be borderline diabetic, and to make these tough choices day after day until your body and mind begins to adjust to them. It's not easy, and there is no strategy for weight loss that is easy. If you undergo gastric bypass surgery, you might say, "Well, that was easy." But the fact is, it's not easy on your body, and it's not easy on your long-term health.

We are just beginning to experiment with gastric bypass surgery on a large-scale basis. As a society we do not know the long-term implications of living with part of your digestive system removed. Gastric bypass surgery, like all surgical procedures, does not have to be approved or proven effective in order to be marketed and performed on patients. People who are undergoing this surgical procedure today are the guinea pigs. They are the people who are being tested, and in 10 or 20 years we may find out that this is a terrible mistake, that these people are subject to side effects that we could not have predicted today, and that their lifespan may be just as short as if they had remained overweight. It is a grand experiment, folks, and if you undergo gastric bypass surgery today, you are allowing yourself to be part of this experiment.

Plus, it will cost you or your insurance carrier as much as $40,000 to play the guinea pig and much more if there are any complications.

 
(deactivated member)
on 6/5/07 10:22 pm - PA
I say, just stop talking to her about it.  Agree to disagree. My mom told me I might die, I told her I was already dying.   ALSO, you may want to point out this to her: Adams is an independent journalist with strong ethics who does not get paid to write articles about any product or company. In 2007, Adams launched EcoLEDs, a maker of super bright LED light bulbs that are 1000% more energy efficient than incandescent lights. He also launched an online retailer of environmentally-friendly products (BetterLifeGoods.com) and uses a portion of its profits to help fund non-profit endeavors. He's also the founder of a well known HTML email software company whose 'Email Marketing Director' software currently runs the NewsTarget subscription database This guy makes money off the stuff he is promoting in this article. Kathy
(deactivated member)
on 6/5/07 10:24 pm - PA

FYI the light bulbs are the "natural light" ones that they sell for people that have Seasonal Affective Disorder. Also, there ARE people out there that are 10, 15 and 20 years post op.  A few are members here on OH.  Go to the grads board.

Melissa_C
on 6/5/07 10:51 pm
Thanks so much, Kathy, for the info and being such a great inspiration! Besides, I feel like I have my own "Natural Light" Yanno the saying....'this lil light of mine, I'm gonna let it shine" ~Melissa
mahofl
on 6/5/07 10:29 pm - Goose Creek, SC
I'm with Kathy, just smile and say thanks for your concern. I know its hard not to have the support of your mother.  Mine wasn't fully on board until my Dad fussed at her. Good Luck.  I know you will do great and we will be your cheerleaders Mary
Melissa_C
on 6/5/07 10:53 pm
Thanks Mary! It is difficult to go through knowing my mom isnt really on board...but deep down I KNOW she really just wants whats best, our opinions of what is best is just different things. ~Melissa
poultond2
on 6/5/07 10:32 pm - Belton, SC
Melissa, I read your comments and those of your mom... Wow!  Talk about playing head games with someone!  Here is my take on what she had to say...  Momma, I appreciate your concern... I know that you love me and want the best for me... and this is what is best.  I am not doing this just to "take the easy way out" because this road will be far from easy at times.  In life the things that are worth the most are the things that you have to work toward. And I am working toward being HEALTHY! I want to be able to walk without pain, to sleep without feeling that I am smothering, to do the things that I want to do without feeling that I am on display becasue of me size.  I would rather have the surgery and take the risks, than shorten my life span and do more of the same things that have brought me to this point.  I love you mom, and I appreciate everything that you have done for me, but this time I need to do this for myself..... I don't know if that will help you, but my mom was against the surgery for a long time, until she saw that I had weighed the risks... she is now one of my biggest supporters.... I'll be praying for you!! Donna Jo
Melissa_C
on 6/5/07 10:55 pm
Thanks for the kind words, Donna Jo! My greatest hope is that by the end of the year when I am on the losing side, she will realize what a blessing this surgery is to me....and by the way...HOW are YOU doing??? ~Melissa
poultond2
on 6/5/07 11:00 pm - Belton, SC
I am good... down 31 lbs (at last count) and am on the soft solid food plan... Grits and cheese are my new best friends!  Am back into a 22/24 from a 30/32 size in 1 month.. no more feet swelling, back ache, knees don't hurt... what more could I ask for? Life is good on the losing side! Have a great day and keep focusing on YOUR health!! Donna Jo
Julie P.
on 6/5/07 11:24 pm - Charleston, SC
Ok first off, Agree to Disagree.  Tell your Mom to drop it!  You hear her concerns but you have done the research and this is your choice not hers and this is what you feel is the best for you.  You are not a child, you are an adult and able to make your own decisions!   Next the article, natural sunlight - PLEEAAASE!  First they saying being out the in sun gives you cancer (which is true I know), now they are saying that we need to get more natural sunlight so we can lose weight!  OK, when I was young, I lived outside, and I was still overweight!   Regular exercise takes away Carbo craving---NOT!!!!!  For 5 years I walked 3-5 days a week up to 3-4 miles at a time, what you would consider regular exercise, I did not lose a pound NOR did those Carbo cravings go away!  Now I will admit that if I do exercise when I am wanting to eat, it does subide it, but it does not go away! I do not know about your program but our Dr. B had you list all the diets you had tried, plus most insurance companies reguire that you have tried a medically supervised diet before even being considered for WLS! Now the money...You will cost your insurance company more in the long run with all the complications of being obese than you will with the WLS, my opinion mind you.  But think about it,   Add up all the medication and Dr visit you do for diabetes and HBP and other Co-morbs that go along with being obese.  I was taking Starlix, for diabetes, for over a year before surgery.  That was $25/30 days for me and over $100/30 day bill to the insurance company.  Not to mention I had to go back to my Dr on regular time schedule and refills and blood work.  My insurance company probably spent more in that one year than they shelled out for my surgery. I am sorry I just rambled, but articles like that really make me mad .  Yes I had it VERY easy to the point that it does look like this is the easy way out, but it is not!  I am sorry you are not getting the positive support from you Mom.  I can only image how tough that it is.  But you have us! Julie

I can go the distance... I do not care how far... I know every mile will be worth my while.

My goal in life is to be as good of a person as my DOGS already think I am!

 Julie 



Most Active
Recent Topics
Charleston MUSC patients
MsRadar65 · 0 replies · 419 views
Overstitch Surgeon?
Pamela G. · 1 replies · 3170 views
Greenville sc
ebonymc · 0 replies · 4092 views
Union,SC
Tracy6035 · 0 replies · 4430 views
×